Table 1.
Immobilization | Technique | LOD | LR | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
GCE/MWCNTs-ILs/Thi)/anti-PSA/PSA/HRP-labeled PSA | DPV | 20 pg/mL | 0.2 – 40 ng/mL | [33] |
AuNWs/anti-PSA doped polypyrole/BSA/PSA | DPV | 0.3 pg/mL | 10 fg/mL – 10 ng/mL | [34] |
GCE/GO/Chi/anti-PSA+Thi/PSA/AuNPs–PAMAM/aptamer | DPV EIS |
10 fg/mL 5 pg/mL |
0.1 pg/mL– 90ng/mL 0.05 – 35 ng/mL |
[35] |
GCE/MWCNTs/IL/Chi-AuNPs-PAMAM)/ PhCl/anti-PSA+Thi/PSA/HRP- anti-PSA | DPV EIS |
1 pg/mL 0.5 ng/mL |
0.05 – 80 ng/mL 5 – 25 ng/mL |
[36] |
AuNano/OEGMA-co-GMA/anti-PSA/PSA/Si-NPs-Ab2 | DPV | 2 pg/mL | 5 pg/mL – 1000 ng/mL | [37] |
GCE/NH2-GS–FcCOH/anti-PSA/PSA/Ab2 | EIS | 2 pg/mL | 0.01 – 10 ng/mL | [38] |
GCE/GS-AuNPs/anti-PSA/PSA | CV | 0.59 ng/mL | 0 – 10 ng/mL | [39] |
GCE/Ag@MSNs/anti-PSA/BSA/PSA | CV | 15 pg/mL | 0.05 – 50 ng/mL | [40] |
Au/SAM1/NH2-PEG3-biotin/avidin/biotin-anti-PSA/PSA/HRP-anti-PSA | EIS | 0.51 ng/mL* | 2 – 24 ng/mL | [27] |
Au/anti-PSA/PSA/anti-PSA - coated with enzyme-encapsulated liposomes | LSV | 7 pg/mL | 0.01 – 100 ng/mL | [41] |
Au/SAM2/anti-PSA | EIS | 10 pg/mL | 1.1 – 53 pg/mL | [25] |
SPE/array of holes in a polymer/polyaniline/biotin/avidin/biotin-anti-PSA | EIS | 1 ng/mL # 1 pg/mL # |
1 – 100 ng/mL # 1 – 100 pg/mL # |
[26] |
Au/SAM3/protein A/BSA/anti-PSA(total) Au/SAM3/protein A/BSA/anti-PSA(free) |
EIS EIS |
1 ng/mL 1 ng/mL |
1 – 10 ng/mL 1 – 10 ng/mL |
[28] |
Au/SAM4/anti-PSA | EIS | 130 ag/mL | 130 ag/mL – 1 ug/mL • | [20] |
Au/SAM5/anti-PSA/CF/PSA from human serum/lectin | EIS | 100 ag/mL & | 100 ag/mL – 1 ug/mL • | This study |
LOD: limit of detection, LR: linear range, GCE: glassy carbon electrode, IL: ionic liquids, Thi: thionine, PSA: prostate-specific antigen, anti-PSA: antibody against PSA, MWCNTs: multi-walled carbon nanotubes, HRP: horseradish peroxidase, DPV: differential pulse voltammetry, AuNWs: gold nanowires, BSA: bovine serum albumin, GO: graphene oxide, Chi: chitosan, AuNPs–PAMAM: polyamidoamine dendrimer encapsulated gold nanoparticles, PhCl: phtaloyl chloride, AuNano/OEGMA-co-GMA: nanostructured-Au/polymer brush of [oligo(ethylene glycol)methacrylate-co-glycidyl methacrylate, SiNP: silica nanoparticles, Ab2: secondary antibody, FcCOH: ferrocenecarboxaldehyde, GS: graphene sheets, Ag@NH2-MCM48: silver hybridized mesoporous silica, AuNPs: gold nanoparticles, CV: cyclic voltammetry, Ag@MSNs: silver hybridized mesoporous silica nanoparticles, SAM1: self-assembled monolayer HS-C16-COOH/EG3SH, LSV: linear sweep voltammetry, SAM2: various dithiols with –COOH terminations, SPE: screen printed carbon electrode, SAM3: HS--C11-COOH/HS-C2-OH, SAM4: HS--C11-COOH/HS-C6-OH, SAM5: HS-C11-COOH/HS-C6-OH, CF: carbo-free buffer,* - total PSA, # - depending on the way anti-PSA is immobilized, & - this value was extrapolated, •- semilogarithmic calibration curve.