Table 4.
Group support psychotherapy (GSP) | Group HIV education (GHE) | ||
---|---|---|---|
Group facilitators | Group members | Group facilitators | Group members |
Facilitators of intervention delivery | |||
Intrapersonal factors | Intrapersonal factors | ||
Formal and informal training received | Keen interest and eagerness to learn | Some prior knowledge on HIV related issues | Keen interest and eagerness to learn Had some prior knowledge of the HIV topics |
Prior mental health knowledge | Perceived GFs as supportive and respectful | Perceived GFs as supportive and respectful Adequate time was allocated to question and answer session |
|
Program factors | Program factors | ||
Availability of intervention manual | Provision of transport allowance | Availability of intervention manual | Provision of transport allowance |
Intervention content easy to follow | Provision of refreshments during sessions | Intervention content easy to follow | Provision of refreshments during sessions |
Provision of financial incentive | GFs never missed a group session | Provision of financial incentive | GFs never missed a group session |
Open communication channels with trainers | Intervention content culturally sensitive | Open communication channels with trainers | Intervention content culturally sensitive |
Gender and cultural factors | Gender and cultural factors | ||
Allowed to elect their own group leader | Allowed to elect their own group leader | ||
Allowed to have an opening and closing ritual | Allowed to have an opening and closing ritual | ||
Allowed to give the group a traditional name | Allowed to give the group a traditional name | ||
Having gender specific sessions | Having gender specific sessions | ||
Barriers of intervention delivery | |||
Intrapersonal factors | Intrapersonal factors | ||
Impatience with slow learners and those intoxicated with alcohol | Poor time management | Feelings of guilt experienced when not able to teach coping skills yet GMs were emotionally unwell and some were intoxicated with alcohol | Some GMs were always intoxicated with alcohol |
Limited knowledge on emotional self-care | Some GMs were always intoxicated with alcohol | Limited knowledge of ART medications | |
Program factors | Program factors | ||
Intervention manual was not translated to the local language | Absence of writing material for GMs | Intervention manual was not translated to the local language | Some GMs were unhappy and disgruntled when they realized that they were not learning the same skills taught in GSP |
A few GMs complained of long distances between their homes and meeting venue | Sessions lacked information on Alcohol use problems | Absence of writing material for GMs who needed them | |
Financial incentive considered inadequate by the male GFs | Change of meeting venue without prior notice | Financial incentive considered inadequate by the male GFs | GMs not allowed to share their personal experiences |
Lack of a co-facilitator increased work load | Time allocated for sharing personal problems not enough for GMs | Sessions not interactive and did not include practical sessions | No practical sessions given |
Group size of 10–12 considered large given the multiple problems of PLWH | Meeting venue in mental health clinics were unpleasant to GMs | Lack of a co-facilitator increased work load | |
Gender and cultural factors | Gender and cultural factors | ||
GMs missed sessions due conflicting work schedules and burial attendances | Some husbands refused to grant permission to their wives to attend sessions Female GMs brought children to group sessions |