Skip to main content
. 2017 Sep 19;6:e49. doi: 10.1017/jns.2017.45

Table 4.

Difference in energy intake (kJ) of different food groups and Lin's concordance correlations (LCC) between the self-administered web-based and the interviewer-administered telephone-based 24-h dietary recalls (n 514)

(Mean values and standard deviations, proportional differences and LCC)

Web-based 24-h recalls Telephone-based 24-h recalls Difference between both recall methods LCC
Mean sd Mean sd Mean sd %* P
Alcoholic beverages 465 583 462 521 3 444 0·4 0·88 0·68
Bread 1493 669 1518 665 −25 513 −3·5 0·27 0·70
Cereal products and binding agents 433 573 471 476 −38 576 −5·3 0·14 0·40
Cheese 435 336 509 358 −74 371 −10·4 <0·0001 0·42
Coffee, tea and water 21 14 73 157 −52 155 −7·3 <0·0001 0·02
Composite dishes 253 488 254 446 0 662 −0·0 1·00 0·00
Eggs 87 128 88 129 −1 144 −0·1 0·89 0·38
Fats, oils and savoury sauces 530 361 647 351 −118 424 −16·5 <0·0001 0·28
Fish 134 248 177 278 −43 327 −6·0 0·00 0·23
Fruit 419 356 461 340 −43 321 −6·0 0·00 0·57
Fruit/vegetable juices, soft drinks 200 259 237 278 −36 250 −5·1 0·00 0·56
Legumes 35 105 30 103 5 127 0·7 0·35 0·25
Meat, meat products and poultry 661 515 725 488 −64 576 −8·9 0·01 0·34
Milk and milk products 698 436 779 465 −81 404 −11·3 <0·0001 0·59
Nuts, seeds and snacks 429 520 462 542 −32 554 −4·5 0·19 0·46
Pastry, cake and biscuits 612 530 616 501 −4 589 −0·6 0·86 0·35
Potatoes 309 333 309 322 0 418 −0·0 0·99 0·19
Savoury sandwich fillings 75 168 67 150 8 153 1·1 0·25 0·54
Soups 89 142 77 138 11 176 1·6 0·14 0·21
Soya and vegetarian products 57 151 65 160 −7 142 −1·0 0·25 0·58
Sugar and confectionery 390 365 482 420 −92 409 −12·9 <0·0001 0·45
Vegetables 162 119 189 125 −26 137 −3·7 <0·0001 0·36
*

Proportional difference is calculated as ((mean of web-based 24 h recall) – (mean of telephone-based 24 h recall))/(mean difference in kJ) × 100. The mean difference between the methods is −714 kJ (Table 2).