Table 4.
OLS Models of County Outmigration – Climate Models
Climate failure | Climate with ecodivisions | Climate with ecodivisions (robust) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||
DIAGNOSTICS | R squared | 0.8458 | 0.8655 | 0.9210 |
| ||||
Adj. R squared | 0.8454 | 0.8647 | 0.9206 | |
| ||||
F statistic | 2100 on 8 and 3062 DF | 1155 on 17 and 3053 DF | ||
| ||||
Shapiro test W value | 0.8213 | 0.7852 | 0.7728 | |
| ||||
Breusch-Pagan p value | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | |
| ||||
VIF values >3 | ecodiv, temperature | log of pop, ecodiv, max temperature | ||
| ||||
Moran’s I (if significant) | 0.3569 | 0.2688 | ||
| ||||
INDEPENDENT VARIABLES | Odds (sig.) | Odds (sig.) | Odds (sig.) | |
| ||||
Population | 2.3751 *** | 2.4558 *** | 2.4000 *** | |
| ||||
Crop failure (ref=0%) | ||||
Crop failure 1-5% | ||||
Crop failure 5-25% | ||||
Crop failure >25% | ||||
| ||||
% change in 1934 average daily max temperature from 20 year normal | 1.0175 *** | 1.0069 ** | 1.0074 *** | |
| ||||
% change in 1934 total precipitation from 20 year normal | 0.9951 *** | 0.9940 *** | 0.9950 *** | |
| ||||
% of population in retail employment, 1930 | 1.0857 *** | 1.0447 *** | 1.0592 *** | |
| ||||
% of population in manufacturing employment, 1930 | 0.9815 *** | 0.9866 *** | 0.9825 *** | |
| ||||
Weighted % change in 3 top crops production, 1930-1940 | 0.9991 *** | 0.9993 *** | 0.9995 *** | |
| ||||
Est. % of working age (15-64) population unemployed, 1937 | 1.0018 | 1.0067 ** | 1.0082 *** | |
| ||||
County is urban | 0.9253 * | 0.9266 * | 0.9717 | |
| ||||
Ecodivisions (ref= warm continental) | ||||
Hot continental | 1.0144 | 1.0306 | ||
Subtropical | 1.1941 *** | 1.2674 *** | ||
Prairie | 1.3636 *** | 1.3479 *** | ||
Temperate steppe | 1.3812 *** | 1.3633 *** | ||
Subtropical & tropical steppe | 1.7012 *** | 1.7037 *** | ||
Subtropical & tropical desert | 1.4150 *** | 1.4617 *** | ||
Temperate desert | 1.3686 *** | 1.3221 *** | ||
Mediterranean | 1.7142 *** | 1.6475 *** | ||
Marine | 1.9351 *** | 1.8888 *** |
Significance codes:
0
0.001
0.01
0.05