Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 9;6(11):e1356148. doi: 10.1080/2162402X.2017.1356148

Table 1.

Study characteristics of studies included in meta-analysis. Oral Cavity (OC), Oropharynx (OP), Hypopharynx (HP), Larynx (L), Other (O), Surgery (S), Radiotherapy (RT), Chemotherapy (CT), Chemoradiotherapy (CRT), Formalin Fixed, Paraffin Embedded material (FFPE), Fresh Frozen Tissue (FFT), Tissuemicroarray (TMA), Immunohistochemistry (IHC), Immunofluorescence Staining (IFS).

Study Sample size Subsite HPV Stage Treatment Biomarkers Material Technique
Balermpas 2014 101 OC, OP, HP, L Both All CRT CD3, CD4, CD8, FoxP3 FFPE IHC
Bron 2013 35 OC, OP, HP, L ? All S FoxP3, (BDCA2, CD11c, CD56, COX2, BCL2, ARG2, iNOS) FFPE IHC
Distel 2009 115 OP, HP ? All CRT, S+RT CD3, CD4, CD8, FoxP3, (CD20, CD79, Granzyme B) FFPE in TMA IHC
Hasmim 2013 83 OC, OP, HP, L Both All S, CRT, S+RT CD8, (HLA1, EPHRI-NE, SCINDERIN) FFT IHC, IFS
Kim 2016 402 OC, OP, HP, L, O Both All S+CRT/RT/CT CD3, CD8, FoxP3, (PD-L1, PD1, ICOS, LAG-1) FFPE in TMA IHC
Nasman 2012 83 OP Both All RT, CRT CD8, FoxP3 FFPE IHC
Nguyen 2016 273 OC, OP, HP, L ? All S, RT, CRT CD4, CD8, FoxP3, (CD68) FFPE in TMA IHC
Nordfors 2013 280 OP Both All RT, CRT CD4, CD8 FFPE IHC
Oquejiofor 2015 139 OP Both All RT CD3, CD4, CD8, FoxP3, (SMA) FFPE IHC
Park 2013 79 OP Both III/IV S, RT, S+RT FoxP3, CD25 FFPE in TMA IHC
Pretscher 2009 33 OC, OP, HP Both All S+RT, S+CRT CD3, CD8, FoxP3, (CD20, CD68, Granzyme B) FFPE in TMA IHC
Punt 2016 117 OP Both All ? CD3, FoxP3, (IL-17) FFPE IFS
Van Kempen 2016 262 OP Both All S, S+(C)RT, RT, CRT CD3, CD4, CD8, (SERPENB1/B4/B9, Granzyme B) FFPE in TMA IHC
Watanabe 2010 87 OC ? All S CD4, CD8, CD25, FoxP3, (CD69, CCR4, Granzyme B) FFPE IHC
Wolf 2015 39 OC ? All S, S+RT CD4, CD8, FoxP3, (CD104, CD68) FFPE in TMA IHC
Zancope 2010 70 OC, O (lip) ? All S CD8, (CD57) FFPE IHC