Table 1.
Reference Country |
N carers | Participants | Intervention | Length of follow-up | Risk of biasa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Multicomponent carer | |||||
Lawton 1989 (Lawton, Brody, & Saperstein, 1989) United States |
632 | Carers: Mean age 60 80% female PWD: Mean cognitive symptom severity was 14/30 in the control group and 13/30 in the intervention group (moderate severity). |
Intervention included respite, case management, and counseling. A social worker discussed the carer’s needs, assisted where needed in procuring services, and maintained regular contact (at client’s request at any time, with a 2-month maximum interval, initiated by the social worker if necessary) through the 12 months following the baseline interview. Case management and counseling continued, where needed, throughout the year and the respite offer was made when appropriate. | 12 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Mohide 1990 (Mohide et al., 1990) United States |
60 | Carers: Mean age 66 in the intervention group and 69 in the control group Gender 70% in the experimental group and 73% in the control group PWD: Mean MMSE was 13 in the intervention group and 11 in the control group (moderate severity) |
The aim of intervention was to enhance carer competence and achieve a sense of control. Caregiver support nurses scheduled home visits, which were initially weekly. Carers undertook a health assessment, were provided with education, a copy of “The 36-Hour Day,” problem solved strategies to reduce excessive disability, and enhance functional capacity in the PWD. Carers were offered a 4-hr block of in-home respite weekly. Carers were encouraged to attend a monthly 2-hr support group. | 3 and 6 months | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Unclear |
Eisdorfer 2003 (Eisdorfer et al., 2003) United States (REACH Miami study) |
225 | Carers: Mean age 69 years, 75% female PWD: Across the subgroups, the average MMSE ranged from 10 to 19/30 (moderate severity) |
A structural family therapy intervention plus technology system designed to facilitate linkages of the carers with both their family and supports outside of the home. The system also provided the therapist with enhanced access to the carer and their family members. Intervention took place over 12 months with weekly sessions for the first 4 months, biweekly sessions for the next 2 months, and monthly sessions for the final 6 months. Each session lasted 60 to 90 min. | 6 and 18 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. High |
Mittelman 2004 (Mittelman, Roth, Coon, & Haley, 2004; Mittelman, Roth, Haley, & Zarit, 2004) Gaugler 2008 United States |
406 | Carers: Mean age 71 60% female PWD: The majority of participants had a Global Deterioration Scale score of 4 (mild severity) |
Caregivers in the treatment group received a comprehensive intervention that was designed to maximize the support provided to them. They agreed to participate in individual and family counseling sessions and to join and regularly attend an AD caregiver support group. They and their families could request additional help, advice, or counseling at any time. Education was a key element of the intervention. There was no predefined endpoint to the treatment. Formal counseling was the central structured component of the treatment. There were two sessions with the caregiver alone and four sessions with the caregiver and the family | 4, 8, and 12 months | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. High 5. High 6. Unclear |
Belle 2006 (Belle et al., 2006) Nichols United States |
642 | Carers: Mean age was 57 to 64 in the various treatment and participant groups 81% to 90% female depending on treatment and participant groups PWD: Mean MMSE ranged from 8 to 10/30 across the different subgroups (moderate severity) |
The intervention addressed caregiver depression, burden, self-care, and social support and care recipient problem behaviors through 12 in-home and telephone sessions over 6 months. Key strategies for intervention included education about pleasant events and well-being, stress management techniques, importance of looking after own health, social support, and the symptoms of dementia. Carers were supported to manage BPSD and given prescriptions with step-by-step strategies to manage these. | 6 Months | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Unclear |
Finkel 2007 (Finkel et al., 2007) United States |
46 | Carers: Mean age 65; 68% female PWD: Severity not reported |
Primary component of intervention delivery was the CTIS. Carers could (a) place and receive calls, (b) send and retrieve messages, (c) access information and services, and (d) conference with several people simultaneously. Intervention was provided over 6 months and included 2 in-home sessions and 12 sessions conducted over the CTIS. Eight individual educational skill-building sessions and six support group sessions were interspersed. | 6 months postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Unclear |
Tremont 2008 (Tremont, Davis, Bishop, & Fortinsky, 2008) United States |
33 | Carers: Mean age Intervention group 66 Control group 61 Gender not reported PWD: 22 care recipients had mild dementia and 11 had moderate dementia. (mild severity) |
Telephone based psychosocial intervention (called FITT-D). Twenty-three phone calls over 1 year. Involved emotional support, direction to resources, encouraging families, and carers’ health and teaching families and carers’ strategies | 1 year | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. High |
Davis 2011 (Davis, Tremont, Bishop, & Fortinsky, 2011) United States |
46 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 57, control group 61 Gender intervention group 83% female, control group 68% female PWD: Severity not reported |
FITT-NH intervention. Delivered via 10 phone calls over 3 months for families and carers whose loved one had moved into a care home. Incorporated emotional adjustment, families– and carers–staff interaction, family functioning, health behaviors, and social support and role change. | Postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Low 6. High |
Kuo 2012 (Kuo et al., 2013) Taiwan |
129 | Carers: Mean age 80, 54% female PWD: 36% had mild dementia, 34% had moderate dementia, 30% had severe dementia (moderate severity) |
Intervention comprised a two-session, in-home training program. Each session was 1 week apart. Sessions lasted 2 to 3 hr. BPSD were identified and a plan formulated to minimize stimuli, and modify daily schedule and environment. The second session involved education and confirming the action plan. One week after the second visit and then once a month for up to 6 months the research nurse made follow-up phone calls. | 2 weeks, 3 months, and 6 months postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. High 6. Unclear |
Joling 2012 (Joling et al., 2012) Netherlands |
192 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 68, control group 71 Gender 70% female PWD: Mean MMSE was 21/30 (mild severity) |
Six sessions were held over a year. Intervention was tailored to the needs of the families and carers and included psychoeducation, problem solving techniques, and engaging family networks to enhance support. Issues such as management of behavioral problems and coping with feelings of guilt were addressed. Ad hoc telephone counseling was available beyond the scheduled sessions. | Month 12 postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. High |
Gaugler 2013 (Gaugler, Reese, & Mittelman, 2013) United States |
107 | Carer: Mean age 50 Gender: All female PWD: Mean severity on the Global Deterioration Scale was 4.97. (moderate severity) |
Individual and family counseling, support group participation, and ad hoc counseling over a 4-month intervention period. | Quarterly during Year 1 and then every 6 months for a minimum of 2 years | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Livingston 2013 (Livingston et al., 2013) Knapp 2013 United Kingdom |
260 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 62, control group 56 Gender intervention group 67% female, control group 71% female PWD: Mean severity on the clinical dementia scale was 1.3 indicating mild to moderate severity (mild severity) |
A manual-based coping intervention comprising eight sessions. The program consisted of psychoeducation about dementia, carers’ stress, and where to get emotional support; understanding behaviors of the family member being cared for and behavioral management techniques; changing unhelpful thoughts; promoting acceptance; assertive communication; relaxation; planning for the future; increasing pleasant activities; and maintaining skills learnt. Carers practiced these techniques at home, using the manual and relaxation CDs. | Months 4, 8 | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Low |
Martindale-Adams 2013 (Martindale-Adams, Nichols, Burns, Graney, & Zuber, 2013) United States |
154 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 66, control group 65 Gender intervention group 82% female, control group 86% PWD: Mean MMSE 15/30 (moderate severity) |
Telephone support groups involving 5 to 6 families and carers and a group leader. The group met for 14 sessions over 1 year. Families and carers were provided with written materials on managing behaviors of concern and coping with stress. The intervention focused on education, skills building, and support. | Months 6 and 12 | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Low 6. High |
Gonzalez 2014 (Gonzalez, Polansky, Lippa, Gitlin, & Zauszniewski, 2014) United States |
102 | Carers: Mean age 62 in the intervention group and 58 in the control group Gender: All female PWD: Severity not reported |
Six group sessions on resourcefulness training in groups of 5 to 7 carers who met for 2 hr weekly. The training taught and reinforced cognitive behavioral skills, coping strategies, problem solving, priority setting, and decision making. | Postintervention and 12 weeks after the intervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Au 2014 (Au, Wong, Leung, Leung, & Wong, 2014) Hong Kong |
60 | Carers: Mean age 58 in intervention group and 55 in control group. Gender: 78% female PWD: Mean MMSE 15.5 in intervention group and 12.9 in the control group (moderate severity) |
Pleasant event scheduling for the caregivers and discussion and support around coping with caregiving. | Postintervention and 1 month following intervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Chen 2015 (Chen, Huang, Yeh, Huang, & Chen, 2015) Taiwan |
46 | Carers: Mean age 55 Gender; 67% female PWD: Approximately 63% had CDR score of 1 and 37% had a CDR score of 2 (mild severity) |
Study nurses provided the intervention of six sessions over 3 months. Sessions included improving knowledge of dementia, providing information regarding support services, techniques to manage BPSD or cognitive difficulties, support in relaxation and coping, and establishing a caregiver self-support system. | Postintervention | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Gaugler 2015 (Gaugler, Reese, & Sauld, 2015) United States |
36 | Carers: Mean age 63, 81% female PWD: NPI-Q severity mean 9.89 out of 30 in the total group (moderate severity) |
Residential Care Transition Module to help families manage their emotional and psychological distress following residential care placement of a cognitively impaired relative. Intervention included psychoeducation, communication, problem solving, behavior management strategies, concrete planning, and counseling. | At 4 months and 8 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. High 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Multicomponent carers plus people with dementia | |||||
Zarit 1982 (Zarit, Zarit, & Reever, 1982) United States |
35 | Carers: Not reported PWD: Not reported |
Classes with problem solving training involving taking practical steps to manage day-to-day problems caused by the memory loss. Participants, including both the individuals with dementia and the caregivers, were asked to talk about specific instances of “forgetting” that were troublesome. Suggestions for managing these problems were made by group leaders or other participants, taking into account an individual’s severity of memory loss, living arrangements, and personal resources. The classes met twice a week for 1.5 hr a session for 3.5 weeks, or seven sessions | Postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Chang 1999
(Chang, 1999) United States |
65 | Carers: Mean age 67 All females PWD: Not reported |
The intervention was designed to provide the caregiver with knowledge and skills to improve the PWD’s eating and dressing abilities. It involved (a) videotapes demonstrating assisted modeling behavior (eating and dressing) and (b) a Nurseline support program to reinforce the video information and assist the caregiver to explore coping strategies. | 4, 8, and 12 weeks | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Quayhagen 2000 (Quayhagen et al., 2000) United States |
103 | Carers: Mean age 72 63% female PWD: Severity not reported |
Dyadic counseling, namely, problem (conflict) identification, stress reduction, anger/frustration management, communication enhancement, and conflict resolution. The family (caregiver and PWD) focused on problems and/or conflicts that reduced their ability to interact effectively accompanied by tasks oriented to increasing communication and problem solving skills and enhancing the relationship. The dual participation continued to offer cognitive stimulation to the patient while working on social and emotional issues of concern to the couple. Each of the intervention programs was conducted for 8 weeks and included the participation of both members of the caregiving dyad. Three of the four programs were 1.5 hr in length, while the fourth program, the early-stage day care, was conducted for 4 hr weekly for the patients, but had only two sessions for the caregivers, with respite time an intended aspect of this intervention. | Postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Buckwalter 1999 (Buckwalter et al., 1999) Gerdner 2002 (Gerdner, Buckwalter, & Reed, 2002) Stolley 2002 (Stolley, Reed, & Buckwalter, 2002) United States |
245 | Carers: Mean age 65 years 75% female PWD: Severity not reported |
Community-based psychoeducational nursing intervention to teach carers to manage BPSD. The individualized plan of care based on the PLST model was presented and practiced utilizing examples with return demonstration during the in-home sessions. The care plan was reviewed, techniques taught, and written materials summarizing the care plan were provided at the second in-home session 1 week later. Referrals for support groups, legal counseling, and case management services were provided as indicated. Experimental subjects received a total of approximately 3 to 4 hr of in-home intervention following baseline assessment and biweekly follow-up phone calls from a research team member for the first 6 months of the study. | 6 months, 12 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3.High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Chu 2000 (Chu, Edwards, Levin, & Thompson, 2000) Canada |
78 | Carers: 68% of carers older than 75 Equal numbers of males and females PWD: Mean MMSE 22/30 (mild severity) |
The Early Home Care Program provided case management, occupational therapy, physiotherapy, social work, nursing, respiratory therapy, respite, homemaking, personal care assistance, volunteer service, and psychiatric consultation. The objectives were to (a) initiate long-term planning early to issues such as housing, finance, legal matters, and caregiving support; (b) increase the early use of home care and other community services; (c) improve the coping strategies related to psychosocial issues that often hinder long-term planning and service utilization; and (d) improve caregiving strategies related to functional and BPSD. | 3, 6, 10, 14, and 18 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Gitlin 2001 (Gitlin, Corcoran, Winter, Boyce, & Hauck, 2001) United States |
171 | Carers: Mean age 61 73% female PWD: Severity of dementia not reported |
Intervention was a targeted, multicomponent program led by an occupational therapist. It involved educating caregivers about the impact of the environment on dementia-related behaviors and helping caregivers simplify objects in the home (e.g., remove clutter), break down tasks (e.g., one- or two-step commands, lay out clothing in the order in which it is to be donned), and involve other members of the family network or formal supports in daily caregiving tasks. For example, occupational therapists provided education about dementia and the relationship between excess stimulation (auditory and visual) and behavioral disturbances such as agitation or resistance to assistance with self-care. Strategies such as removing objects to simplify the home and breaking down tasks provided primary control mechanisms by which caregivers could manage problems areas, such as agitation or the inability to follow directions or initiate tasks by the PWD. The program consisted of five 90-min sessions that were spaced approximately every other week over 3 months. | 3 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Garand 2002 (Garand et al., 2002) United States |
39 | Carers: Mean age 65 92% female PWD: Severity of dementia not reported |
Intervention involved two consultations, each lasting approximately 3 hr. During the first home visit, the interventionist focused on developing a therapeutic relationship with the caregiver while teaching underlying principles of the PLST model and instructing caregivers in the use of behavioral logs. At the second home visit, the plan of care was reviewed, specific behavioral techniques were taught, and the therapeutic relationship was reinforced. A plan for home safety was also outlined during this phase of the intervention and supporting literature was left with the caregiver. Referrals for support groups, legal counsel, and case management were provided. Phase 2 of the intervention consisted of telephone contacts with subjects (by the same interventionist), approximately every other week, for 6 months. Throughout both phases of the intervention, caregivers were encouraged to discuss feelings associated with the caregiving experience, as well as general life stressors they encountered, and to be actively involved in the care planning process. | Postintervention; 6 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. High 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Gitlin 2003 (Gitlin, Hauck, Dennis, & Winter, 2005; Gitlin et al., 2003) Gitlin 2005 United States |
255 | Carers: Mean age 61 76% female PWD: Mean MMSE 12/30 (moderate severity) |
“Home Environmental Skill-Building Program” Occupational therapists provided caregivers with education, problem solving, and technical skills (task simplification, communication), and simple home modifications. The goal was to help caregivers modify the environment to support care recipient physical functioning and reduce behavioral occurrences as well as to reduce caregiver burden. Active treatment, consisting of five 90-min home visits and one telephone session, occurred over 6 months. Maintenance, consisting of one home visit and three brief telephone sessions to reinforce strategy use and obtain closure, occurs over the subsequent 6 months. |
6, 12 months | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Nobili 2004 (Nobili et al., 2004) Italy |
69 | Carers: Mean age 53 in the intervention group and 59 in the control group. Gender: 74% female in the control group and 89% female in the intervention group. PWD: Mean MMSE 12 in the control group and 11 in the intervention group (moderate severity) |
Structured intervention involving one home visit with an OT and one with a psychologist. 1. Analysis of the data collected by researchers during the baseline assessment of patients and principal carer; 2. Home visit by the psychologist to assess and give advice on relationships within the family, care burden of carer and psychological consequences, changes in personality, verbal and nonverbal communication, how problems are dealt by the family and carer, psychological support, and training to carer; 3. Home visit by the occupational therapist to suggest strategies for the control of reactive behaviors and to maintain or improve residual functional ability, modification to home barriers, and adaptation of the environment to meet the patient’s needs to limit dangerous situation. |
6, 12 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Bottino 2005 (Bottino et al., 2005) Brazil |
13 | Carer details not reported PWD: Mean MMSE was 23.5 in the intervention group and 21.3 in the control group (mild severity) |
Cognitive rehabilitation consisted of 90-min group sessions, once a week, designed to stimulate patients’ cognitive functions and to enhance ADL and social interaction. Simultaneously, caregivers (either a familiar or a professional caregiver) attended support group sessions. This group aimed to offer support and to prevent early stress caused by the strain and burden of dementia caregiving, sharing information about the disease, and how to take care of the patient. Caregivers were always instructed to repeat some exercises at home in between the group sessions at least 3 times a week. | Postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Low 6. Unclear |
Martin-Cook 2005 (Martin-Cook, Davis, Hynan, & Weiner, 2005) United States |
49 | Carers: Age not reported 70% female PWD: Mean MMSE 19/30 (mild severity) |
Intervention involved four weekly skills-training sessions. In Session 1, the TFLS was administered to the patient while observed by the caregiver. In Session 2, the TFLS was readministered with the addition of breaking tasks into smaller steps, as well as other visual, auditory, tactile, or multimodal cues and prompts to facilitate improved performance. Caregivers were told that the goal was for patients to complete as many of the IADL tasks as independently as possible, but that assistance should be rendered when patients seemed unable to proceed on their own. In Session 3, the caregiver administered the TFLS, using facilitative prompts and cues as appropriate. The study coordinator offered suggestions and input as needed to assist caregivers in cueing specific tasks. Session 4 integrated the experience of the previous three sessions. Individualized suggestions to enhance communication and specific strategies to facilitate cueing on ADL were reviewed. Practical advice regarding home safety and information about community resources, companion service agencies, and other home health services was offered. | Postintervention; 10 weeks postintervention | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Graff 2006 (Graff et al., 2008; Graff et al., 2006; Graff et al., 2007) Graff 2007 Graff 2008 The Netherlands |
135 | Carers: Mean age 66 in intervention group; mean age 61 in control group 70% female Mean MMSE 19/30 (mild severity) |
Treatment consisted of 10 1-hr sessions delivered by OTs and held over 5 weeks and focused on both patients and their primary caregivers. In the first four sessions of diagnostics and goal defining, patients and primary caregivers learnt to choose and prioritize meaningful activities they wanted to improve. The occupational therapist evaluated the possibilities for modifying patients’ homes and environment and observed patients’ ability to perform relevant daily activities and to use compensatory and environmental strategies. Therapists also observed primary caregivers’ supervision skills. In the remaining six sessions, patients were taught to optimize these compensatory and environmental strategies to improve their performance of daily activities. Primary caregivers were trained, by means of cognitive and behavioral interventions, to use effective supervision, problem solving, and coping strategies to sustain the patients’ and their own autonomy and social participation. The total time spent for the intervention, including the time spent for treatment at home (10 hr), narrative analysis, reports, and multidisciplinary briefing, was about 18 hr per patient and caregiver together. |
Postintervention (6 weeks) and 12 weeks | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. Low 5. Low 6. Low |
Stocking 2007 (Stocking et al., 2007) United States |
149 | Caregiver details not reported PWD: Mean MMSE 20/30 (mild severity) |
Joint completion of the Planning Ahead Together document, a research advance directive. | Postintervention, 2 years | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Chien 2008 (Chien & Lee, 2008) Hong Kong |
88 | Carers: Mean age 44 64% female PWD: 80% of the patients presented with low to moderate impairments in ADLs (mild severity) |
Education and support group for family members that lasted for 6 months. A multidisciplinary committee—including a psychiatrist, a social worker, a case manager (nurse) from each center, and the researchers—selected 25 intervention objectives from dementia guidelines and designed an information and psychological support system linking case managers and dementia care services, health professionals, and referrals. Case managers coordinated all levels of family care according to the results of a structured needs assessment. Each family was assigned one case manager who prioritized problem areas and formulated a multidisciplinary education program for each family on effective dementia care—for example, cognitive stimulation. The program consisted of 12 sessions that were held every other week and lasted two hr each. It consisted of five phases—orientation to dementia care (one session), educational workshop about dementia care (three sessions), family role and strength rebuilding (six sessions), community support resources (one session), and review of program and evaluation (one session). The case managers also conducted home visits and brief education about dementia care every other week and family health assessment once per month. | 6, 12 months | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Low 6. Unclear |
Gitlin 2008 (Gitlin et al., 2008) United States |
60 | Carers: Mean age 65 88% female PWD: Mean MMSE 12/30 (moderate severity) |
Tailored Activity Program: 6 × 90-min home visits and two 15-min telephone contacts by occupational therapists over 4 months. Three activities per patient were developed based on assessments that identified the person’s capacities. The interventionist developed a brief written activity prescription. Carers were instructed in how to facilitate the activity and also in stress reducing techniques to establish a calm emotional tone. As activities were mastered, interventionists generalized strategies to care problems and instructed them on how to downgrade activities for future declines. | 4 months | 1. Low 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Low |
Eloniemi-Sulkava 2009 (Eloniemi-Sulkava et al., 2009) Finland |
125 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 78, control group 77 Gender: Approximately 0.75 were female PWD: Mean MMSE 13 in the intervention group and 14 in the control group (moderate severity) |
Family care coordinator, education sessions, geriatrician, support groups for families and carers, and individualized services. Program lasted for up to 24 months | Months 6, 12, and 24 | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. High 5. Low 6. High |
Logsdon 2010 (Logsdon et al., 2010) United States |
142 | Carers: Mean age intervention group 71, control group 62 Gender 68% PWD: Mean MMSE 23/30 (mild severity) |
Alzheimer’s Association Early Stage Memory Loss Program involves nine sessions for the PWD and families and carers on topics such as information about the condition, relationships, daily living skills, self-esteem, future planning, and legal and financial considerations | Postintervention | 1. High 2. High 3. High 4. Unclear 5. Unclear 6.Unclear |
Gitlin 2010b
United States (Gitlin, Winter, Dennis, Hodgson, & Hauck, 2010) |
272 | Carers: Mean age 66 Gender 82% female PWD: Mean MMSE 13/30 (moderate severity) |
Intervention occurred over 24 weeks and involved up to nine occupational therapy sessions and two nursing sessions plus three phone calls. Goal setting, home assessment, problem solving and action plans, and strategies to reduce families’ and carers’ stress were used and assistive devices provided. The nurse addressed any potential causes of behavioral symptoms related to medical conditions (e.g., pain, dehydration) | Months 4 and 6 | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. Low 5. Unclear 6. Unclear |
Gitlin 2010a
(Gitlin, Winter, Dennis, Hodgson, & Hauck, 2010 United States |
237 | Carers: Mean age 82 Gender: 68% female PWD: Mean MMSE 13/30 (moderate severity) |
“COPE” intervention: Assessment (patient capability, medical testing, home environment, family carer communication, concerns), family carer education (patient capabilities, potential effects of medications, pain, constipation, dehydration), and family carer training to address concerns and help reduce stress. Training in problem solving, communication, engaging patients in activities, and simplifying tasks was tailored to the needs of the dyad. Dyads received up to 10 sessions over 4 months with an occupational therapist | Months 4 and 9 | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4.Low 5. Unclear 6. Low |
Chien 2011 (Chien & Lee, 2011) Hong Kong |
92 | Carers: Mean age 45 Gender 66% PWD: Severity ranged from mild (17%), moderate (50%), to severe (33%; moderate severity) |
Program was conducted fortnightly over 5 months. A multidisciplinary group identified intervention goals. The program included case management, education, support and problem solving, information about relationships, community resources, and improvement of home care and finance skills. Peer mentors helped with problem solving. | Week 1, Month 12 and Month 18 | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. Low 6. Unclear |
Kwok 2012 (Kwok, Lam, & Chung, 2012) Hong Kong |
102 | Carers: Mean age 78 Gender intervention group 59%, control group 56% PWD: Mean MMSE 18/30 (moderate severity) |
Support from case manager via home visits and phone calls, home-based cognitive stimulation activities for the PWD and a telephone hotline to access the case manager. An OT advised on coping strategies, skills training, and behavioral management and linked the person with local services. | Months 4 and 12 | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Unclear 5. High 6. Unclear |
Waldorff 2012 (Waldorff et al., 2012) Phung 2013 Sogaard 2014 Denmark |
330 | Carers: Mean age 66 Gender intervention group 53% female, control group 55% female PWD: Mean MMSE 24/30 (mild severity) |
“DAISY” intervention. Tailored program conducted over 8 to 12 months. Involved up to seven counseling sessions (4-5 with the families and carers present), a group education course about the condition building in peer support, phone call support, written information, and a journal. | 12 months | 1. Low 2. Low 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Low |
Judge 2013 (Judge, Yarry, Looman, & Bass, 2013) United States |
128 | Carers: Mean age 65 Gender 74% female PWD: Mean MMSE 23/30 (mild severity) |
Combines educational skills and cognitive rehabilitation training. Six sessions provided to the dyad covering educational information, effective communication, managing memory, staying active, recognizing emotions, and behaviors | Month 3 | 1. Unclear 2. Unclear 3. High 4. Low 5. High 6. Unclear |
Note. Populations were categorized based on severity. The mean MMSE (or similar) was used where MMSE 19 to 23 was considered mild and MMSE 10 to 18 was considered moderate. REACH = Resources for Enhancing Alzheimer’s Caregiver Health; BPSD = behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia; PWD = person with dementia; AD = Alzheimer’s disease; CG = caregiver education; NPI-Q = Neuropsychiatric Inventory–Questionnaire; OT = occupational therapist; ADL = activities of daily living; DAISY = Danish Alzheimer Intervention Study; MMSE = Mini-Mental State Examination; CTIS = Computer-Telephone Integration System; FITT-D = Family Intervention: Telephone Tracking–Dementia; FITT-NH = Family Intervention: Telephone Tracking–Nursing Home; CD = compact disc; CDR = Clinical Dementia Rating; PLST = progressively lowered stress threshold; IADL = instrumental activities of daily living; COPE = care of persons with dementia in their environments aRisk of bias: (a) random sequence generation, (b) allocation concealment, (c) blinding of participants and personnel, (d) blinding of outcome assessment, (e) incomplete outcome data, (f) selective reporting.