Table 2.
Studies investigating the effect of smokeless tobacco on exercise performance
Study | Participants | Performance protocol | Tobacco intervention | Performance effect |
---|---|---|---|---|
Baldini et al. [3] | 12 habitual smokeless tobacco users abstinent ≥10 h, and 6 non-users as controls | 30-s Wingate test with a resistance of 7.5% bodyweight | 20 min smokeless tobacco use whilst resting supine, then tobacco discarded and performed Wingate test. Four conditions: zero, 1/3 mean, mean, mean +2/3 where ‘mean’ refers to individual average of 10 dips | 5-s peak and 30-s mean power output unaffected by dose and similar to controls |
Van Duser and Raven [58] | 15 habitual smokeless tobacco users abstinent ~12 h | Graded maximal treadmill test at 93.8 m min−1 with incline increasing 2.5% min−1 to volitional exhaustion | 30 min smokeless tobacco use whilst resting seated, then tobacco discarded and performed maximal protocol. 2.5 g smokeless tobacco compared to placebo chew | Not reported but maximal O2 uptake and lactate unchanged |
Escher et al. [21] | 20 habitual smokeless tobacco users, and 20 non-users as controls | Maximum voluntary force and rate of force development using knee extension at 250° s−1 from 90° to 0° of flexion | 2 conditions for habitual users: (1) abstinent ≥12 h and remained abstinent for testing, (2) one dip 2 h prior to and then again on arrival at the laboratory whilst testing | Maximal force (12%) and rate of force development (9–10%) reduced when using smokeless tobacco compared to abstinent |
Morente-Sánchez et al. [45] | 18 non-users/non-smokers | Maximum handgrip strength, maximum countermovement jump height, agility shuttle run, Yo-yo recovery intermittent shuttle test (level 1) | 40 min smokeless tobacco use whilst resting supine, then handgrip strength, countermovement jump and agility shuttle run were performed before tobacco discarded after 70 min and the Yo-yo test was performed. 1.0 g smokeless tobacco compared to placebo chew | All performance tests were unaffected by smokeless tobacco |
Zandonai et al. [62] | 14 non-users/non-smokers | Cycle to volitional exhaustion at 65% maximal aerobic power | Smokeless tobacco use from start of exercise and throughout exhaustion trial. 1.0 g smokeless tobacco compared to placebo chew | Endurance time unaffected with smokeless tobacco |