Skip to main content
. 2017 Sep 5;7(3 Suppl):95S–115S. doi: 10.1177/2192568217701716

Table 1.

Patient, Intervention, Comparators, and Outcomes (PICO).

Study Component Inclusion Exclusion
Participants Adults with traumatic acute spinal cord injury (complete or incomplete)
  • Pediatric patients

  • Pregnancy

  • Penetrating injuries to spinal cord

  • Cord compression due to tumor, hematoma, degenerative disease (eg, CSM)

  • Patients without neurological deficit following trauma

Intervention
  • Early decompression (≤24 hours) via surgery or traction

Comparators
  • Delayed decompression (>24 hours) via surgery or via traction

  • Conservative therapy

Outcomes Efficacy/Effectiveness
  • Neurologic outcomes (eg, Frankel Grade, American Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale)

  • Change in grade

  • Change in motor scores

  • Change in sensation

Functional or Patient Reported Outcomes
  • Functional Independence Measure, ambulatory function, others

Administrative Outcomes
  • Length of stay (intensive care unit, hospital, etc)

Safety Outcomes
  • Complications, adverse events

  • Death

  • Postinjury medical complications

Study design
  • Comparative studies that control for baseline status

  • Animal studies

  • Focus will be on studies with the least potential for bias (RCTs and high-quality comparative studies)

  • Nonclinical studies

  • Case series

  • n < 10 per treatment arm

  • Studies that did not control for baseline neurologic status

  • Studies with different definitions of early and late decompression

Publication
  • Studies in any language with abstracts published in peer-reviewed journals

  • Abstracts, editorials, letters

  • Duplicate publications of the same study that do not report on different outcomes

  • Single reports from multicenter trials

  • White papers

  • Narrative reviews

  • Proceedings/abstracts from meetings

  • Articles identified as preliminary reports when results are published in later versions

Abbreviations: CSM, cervical spondylotic myelopathy; RCT, randomized controlled trial.