Table 1.
Reference | Type of study | Population base | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Hely et al. (2005) | Follow up of a cohort recruited to Bromocriptine vs low dose levodopa study | 130 patients with 52 surviving at 15 years | At 15 or more years falls, autonomic disturbance, neuropsychiatric symptoms, and dementia cause disability Motor fluctuations and dyskinesias while common are less disabling |
Hely et al. (2008) | Follow up of a cohort recruited to Bromocriptine vs low dose levodopa study With 50 age and gender matched controls |
30 surviving patients at 20 years FU | 83% had dementia along with excessive daytime sleepiness 70%, falls 87%, freezing 81%, symptomatic postural hypotension 48%, urinary incontinence in 71%, hallucinations in 74% |
Coelho et al. (2010) | Cross-sectional analysis of an international (Spain-Portugal) out patient cohort | 50 PD patients in HY stages 4–5 (late stage) UPDRS, nonmotor fluctuation, cognition and quality of life assessments |
Motor and nonmotor (mainly non-levodopa responsive symptoms) were prevalent and the main cause of disability. 50%, however, were considered to be non-demented |
Antonini et al. (2015) | Delphi panel—based on consensus | a group of approximately 20 EU neurologists, using 2 rounds of data collection via an online survey and a single in-person meeting | Dementia, hallucinations, psychosis, nonmotor fluctuations, and nighttime sleep disturbances flagged as important potential hallmarks of advanced PD with functional consequences of falls, dependency and risk of pneumonia |
Cilia et al. (2015) | Retrospective, cross-sectional study and longitudinal study | Patients with disease duration ≥ 20 years | Older age at onset and longer disease duration independently associated with a higher prevalence of major motor and nonmotor milestones of disease Mortality associated with male gender, older age, dysphagia, orthostatic hypotension, postural instability, fractures and institutionalisation |
Odin et al. (2015) | International expert recommendations for the management of PD refractory to oral/transdermal therapies | Collection and consensus of opinions on structured questions from 103 experts from 13 countries overseen by an International Steering Committee (ISC) with 13 movement disorder specialists | Patients requiring levodopa > 5 times daily with severe, troublesome ‘off’ periods (> 1–2 h/day) despite optimal oral/transdermal levodopa or non-levodopa-based therapies considered for advanced therapies even if disease duration is < 4 years Cognitive decline related to nonmotor fluctuations is an indication for device-aided therapies |
Luquin et al. (2017) | CEPA Study—a 3-round Delphi study | Including neurologists in Spain and using a Delphi system identification and quantification of clinical variables that characterize patients with APD | Motor syndrome and sleep problems rated as key issues severe dysphagia, recurrent falls, and dementia |
Hassan et al. (2015) | International, multicentre National Parkinson’s Foundation Quality Improvement Initiative (NPF-QII) study database used to identify PD-20 subjects | 187 PD-20 subjects (55% men) (4% of all NPF-QII participants) | (75%) had 20-25 years of PD duration, longest duration being 49 years. PD-20 subjects reflect an elite group of PD survivors with early onset disease and relatively mild cognitive disability despite long disease duration |