Skip to main content
. 2017 Nov 15;7(11):e018606. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018606

Table 1.

Features of studies

Author, year Type of report Study period Location of study Setting of NHS Health Check Data collection method n Method of recruitment to study Participant characteristics Method of analysis
Baker et al, 201515 Journal article Not given South West England 30.1% of total practices delivering NHS Health Checks Surveys including quantitative and qualitative questions 25 Identified randomly via the County Medical List to ensure geographical spread 2 GPs, 14 practice managers, 6 practice nurses, 2 HCAs and 1 administrator Descriptive statistics
Thematic analysis
Crabtree et al, 201017 Conference abstract 2009 Not given 32 (of 35) pharmacies in the area delivering NHS Health Checks Semistructured telephone interviews 32 All 35 pharmacies delivering the service were contacted 15 pharmacists, 13 support staff and 4 pre-registration pharmacists Thematic analysis
NHS Greenwich, 201129 Report 2011 Greenwich Community Open-ended questionnaire 11 All (12) clinicians delivering community outreach services providing NHS Health Checks were invited HCAs, nurses, pharmacists and health trainers Not described
Ismail and Kelly, 201516 Journal article 2010 Yorkshire 25 GPs Semistructured interviews 58 Letters of invitation or flyers to 41 GPs targeted to reflect diversity in terms of performance HCAs, GPs, practice managers, practice nurses and other support staff Framework analysis
Krska et al, 201618 Journal article 2011 Sefton, an area of North West England 33 (of 55) GPs Postal survey with free-text responses 83 (76% of practice managers and 24% of GPs) Personally addressed letters of invitation with a covering letter to all practice managers and GPs at 55 practices 40 practice managers and 43 GPs Categorisation of responses
Loo et al, 201119 Conference abstract 2009 Not given Pharmacies Postal questionnaire 442 (34%) Questionnaire posted to all pharmacies in the area All pharmacists
59% men; 89.1% full-time; 53.4% worked for large multiple pharmacies
Descriptive statistics
McDermott et al, 201620 Journal article 2013–2015 2 London boroughs 17 GPs Semistructured interviews 24 Recruited from within a trial of an enhanced invitation method 52% practice managers, 9% HCAs, 30% administrators, 9% public health leads Framework analysis
McNaughton et al, 201121 Journal article Not given Tees Valley 8 pharmacies Semistructured interviews 20 Postal invitation 10 primary care trust members, 8 pharmacists, 2 representatives from Local Pharmaceutical Committee Thematic analysis
Nicholas et al, 201322 Journal article 2011 2 London boroughs 70 (of 96) GPs Survey with free-text responses 65 Invitations to all 96 GPs 25 practice managers, 8 GPs, 16 practice nurses, 2 HCAs, 3 administrators and 14 not specified Descriptive statistics
Content analysis
Oswald et al, 201028 Evaluation report 2009–2010 Teesside 13 GPs Semistructured interviews 25 Letter of invitation to practice managers 8 practice managers, 14 practice nurses, 1 GP, 1 HCA, 1 pharmacist Thematic analysis
Research Works, 201323 Research report 2013 Not given All settings Semistructured interviews 26 Contacts provided by commissioners with snowballing recruitment 14 commissioners, 12 GPs, practice managers, healthcare assistant, nurse practitioner, physical activity development officer, health bus workers and a community pharmacist Not described
Riley et al, 201525 Journal article 2013 Bristol inner city Community settings Semistructured interviews 4 Participants were recruited via their involvement with community outreach events 1 practice nurse, 1 HCA, 1 engagement worker and 1 health trainer Thematic analysis
Riley et al, 201624 Journal article 2013–2014 Bristol 11 GPs Semistructured interviews 15 18 were invited with purposive sampling 5 GPs, 5 practice nurses, 3 HCAs, 2 pharmacists Thematic analysis
Shaw et al, 201526 Journal article 2010–2011 Birmingham and Black Country GPs and community Semistructured interviews 31 Recruited through lead clinicians 9 GPs, 6 practice managers, 4 practice nurses, 6 HCAs, 1 alternative provider director, 1 call centre manager, 2 call centre operatives and 2 alternative provider registered practice nurses Thematic analysis
Shaw et al, 201627 Journal article Not given Birmingham GPs Semistructured interviews 9 Recruitment undertaken by local NHS trust. No further details were provided All GPs Thematic analysis

GP, general practice; HCA, healthcare assistant; NHS, National Health Service.