Table 5.
Studies of the impact of the ACA DCE on outpatient preventive and behavioral health care
| Paper | Intervention | Control | Time Period | Data Source |
Findings | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age Group |
Sample Size |
Age Group |
Sample Size |
Pre-DCE | Post-DCE | |||
| (Barbaresco et al., 2015) | 23-25 | 49,502 | 27-29 | 68,892 | 1/2007- 9/2010 |
10/2010- 12/2013 |
BRFSS | No effect on flu shot, physical exam or PAP test |
| (Chen et al., 2015) | 19-26 | 9,327 | 27-30 | 4,982 | 1/2008- 12/2009 |
1/2011- 12/2012 |
MEPS | No effect on having ≥1 physician visit |
| (Han, Yabroff, Robbins, Zheng, & Jamal, 2014) | 19-25 | 10,150 | 26-30 | 7,044 | 2009 | 2011- 2012 |
MEPS | Increase in blood pressure measurement. No effect on flu vaccination, PAP test, or physical exams |
| (Kotagal et al., 2014) | 19-25 | Not reported |
26-34 | Not reported |
2009 | 2012 | BRFSS | No effect on physical exam |
| (Kotagal et al., 2014) | 19-25 | Not reported |
26-34 | Not reported |
2009 | 2012 | NHIS | No effect on flu shot |
| (Jhamb et al., 2015) | 19-25 | 21,993 | 27-33 | 26,750 | 2005- 2009 |
2011- 2013 |
NHIS | Increase in number of Dr.’s office visits |
| (Lau, Adams, Park, et al., 2014) | 18-25 | 7,485 | No Control Age Group |
2009 | 2011 | MEPS | Increase in cholesterol screening. No effect on physical exam, blood pressure measurement or flu shot |
|
| (Wallace & Sommers, 2015) | 19-25 | 142,356 | 26-34 | 314,610 | 1/2005- 3/2010 |
9/2010- 12/2012 |
BRFSS | No effect on physical exam |
| (Chua & Sommers, 2014) | 19-25 | 26,453 | 26-34 | 34,052 | 2002- 2009 |
2011 | MEPS | No effect on ≥1 outpatient or primary care visit |
| (Saloner & Le Cook, 2014) | 18-25 | 13,897 | 26-35 | Not reported |
2008- 2010 |
2011- 2012 |
NSDUH | Increase in use of any MH outpatient services. No effect on inpatient, outpatient or private MH care |
| (Saloner & Le Cook, 2014) | 18-25 | 14,705 | 26-35 | Not reported |
2008- 2010 |
2011- 2012 |
NSDUH | No effect on SA treatment of any kind |
BRFSS= Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System; MEPS= Medical Expenditure Panel Survey; NHIS=National Health Interview Survey; NSDUH=National Survey of Drug Use and Health; MH=Mental Health; SA=Substance Abuse