Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Skeletal Radiol. 2017 Aug 29;47(1):93–106. doi: 10.1007/s00256-017-2759-6

Table 3.

Comparison of mean Grey Level Co-occurrence Matrix (GLCM) parameters (95% confidence intervals) between case (n=142) and control (n=426) cohorts. Differences were assessed using linear regression models adjusting for age, BMI, gender, KL-scores, race and PASE in the main analysis and adjusting for BMI, gender, race and PASE in the sensitivity analysis by KL-score. Significant P-values (p < 0.05) are highlighted in bold.

Parameter Non-injured
(n = 426)
Injured
(n = 142)
Adjusted
P-value
Non-injured KL 0&1
(n = 246)
Injured KL0&1
(n = 76)
Adjusted
P-value
Non-injured KL 2
(n= 180)
Injured KL2
(n= 66)
Adjusted
P-value



predicted mean values [95% CI] predicted mean values [95% CI] predicted mean values [95% CI]


Contrast
Global knee contrast 276.16 [269.89, 282.43] 298.84 [287.97, 309.72] <0.001 262.62 [255.10, 270.13] 288.87 [275.34, 302.40] 0.001 293.62 [282.87, 304.37] 312.97 [295.12, 330.81] 0.070
LF contrast 258.04 [252.97, 263.12] 275.47 [266.64, 284.31] <0.001 245.27 [239.30, 251.25] 261.72 [250.95, 272.48] 0.009 274.77 [265.93, 283.61] 294.13 [279.37, 308.88] 0.028
LT contrast 174.44 [168.09, 180.80] 201.13 [190.04, 212.22] <0.001 170.79 [162.58, 179.01] 201.34 [186.55, 216.12] 0.000 179.04 [168.93, 189.16] 202.06 [185.05, 219.07] 0.023
MF contrast 410.34 [400.14, 420.55] 426.49 [408.60, 444.39] 0.125 389.72 [376.65, 402.80] 415.60 [392.16, 439.04] 0.059 437.46 [421.08, 453.84] 443.71 [415.76, 471.67] 0.706
MT contrast 295.51 [284.78, 306.23] 322.95 [304.06, 341.85] 0.014 282.51 [268.66, 296.36] 316.67 [292.12, 341.23] 0.018 312.92 [295.78, 330.06] 331.94 [301.92, 361.96] 0.282
PAT contrast 243.30 [232.21, 254.39] 275.61 [256.16, 295.07] 0.005 227.78 [218.37, 237.20] 251.36 [234.49, 268.23] 0.017 266.12 [242.14, 290.10] 311.28 [270.45, 352.11] 0.062

Entropy
Global knee entropy 6.08 [6.06, 6.11] 6.14 [6.11, 6.18] 0.007 6.07 [6.04, 6.10] 6.13 [6.08, 6.18] 0.029 6.10 [6.07, 6.14] 6.16 [6.10, 6.22] 0.095
LF entropy 6.58 [6.56, 6.60] 6.64 [6.60, 6.67] 0.013 6.55 [6.52, 6.57] 6.61 [6.56, 6.66] 0.032 6.62 [6.59, 6.66] 6.67 [6.61, 6.72] 0.196
LT entropy 5.56 [5.53, 5.60] 5.68 [5.61, 5.74] 0.003 5.56 [5.53, 5.60] 5.68 [5.61, 5.74] 0.037 5.57 [5.51, 5.63] 5.69 [5.59, 5.79] 0.037
MF entropy 6.78 [6.75, 6.80] 6.80 [6.76, 6.84] 0.325 6.74 [6.71, 6.77] 6.78 [6.73, 6.83] 0.195 6.82 [6.78, 6.86] 6.83 [6.76, 6.90] 0.810
MT entropy 5.69 [5.66, 5.72] 5.77 [5.71, 5.82] 0.020 5.66 [5.62, 5.71] 5.71 [5.63, 5.78] 0.336 5.73 [5.68, 5.78] 5.85 [5.77, 5.94] 0.016
PAT entropy 5.84 [5.80, 5.88] 5.83 [5.77, 5.90] 0.822 5.88 [5.83, 5.92] 5.94 [5.86, 6.02] 0.154 5.80 [5.72, 5.87] 5.68 [5.56, 5.81] 0.114

Variance
Global knee variance 199.58 [195.37, 203.80] 215.71 [208.39, 223.03] <0.001 190.14 [185.06, 195.23] 209.15 [200.00, 218.30] <0.001 211.69 [204.52, 218.85] 225.28 [213.39, 237.18] 0.056
LF variance 191.10 [187.47, 194.72] 203.99 [197.68, 210.30] <0.001 181.07 [176.69, 185.46] 193.80 [185.90, 201.70] 0.006 204.19 [198.03, 210.35] 218.05 [207.78, 228.33] 0.024
LT variance 140.84 [136.19, 145.48] 162.43 [154.32, 170.54] <0.001 138.48 [132.13, 144.83] 164.19 [152.77, 175.61] <0.001 143.74 [136.94, 150.54] 161.28 [149.84, 172.71] 0.010
MF variance 283.41 [277.13, 289.69] 291.05 [280.04, 302.06] 0.239 268.19 [260.13, 276.24] 283.39 [268.95, 297.83] 0.072 303.39 [293.37, 313.41] 303.43 [286.32, 320.53] 0.997
MT variance 200.57 [193.77, 207.37] 219.60 [207.61, 231.58] 0.007 191.74 [182.85, 200.63] 215.61 [199.84, 231.38] 0.010 212.35 [201.68, 223.02] 225.53 [206.85, 244.21] 0.231
PAT variance 183.97 [175.76, 192.18] 207.07 [192.67, 221.47] 0.006 174.25 [167.42, 181.08] 191.59 [179.36, 203.82] 0.016 198.29 [180.43, 216.16] 229.72 [199.30, 260.13] 0.081