Table 6.
Methods | Index | RBF Network | Kstar | Random Forest | IBK | Random Tree | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
After variable selection | Delete the rows with missing data | CC | 0.033 | 0.638a | 0.729a | 0.251 | 0.545a |
MAE | 0.182a | 0.121a | 0.111a | 0.199 | 0.135a | ||
RMSE | 0.229 | 0.176a | 0.156a | 0.287 | 0.212a | ||
RAE | 0.992a | 0.657a | 0.602a | 1.083 | 0.736a | ||
RRSE | 1.007 | 0.775a | 0.688a | 1.262 | 0.935a | ||
Series mean | CC | 0.107a | 0.661a | 0.739a | 0.242a | 0.551 | |
MAE | 0.172a | 0.107a | 0.101a | 0.179a | 0.129 | ||
RMSE | 0.221a | 0.167a | 0.151a | 0.268a | 0.205 | ||
RAE | 0.988a | 0.615a | 0.579a | 1.027a | 0.740 | ||
RRSE | 0.995a | 0.753a | 0.678a | 1.208a | 0.923 | ||
Linear | CC | 0.105a | 0.666a | 0.735a | 0.258a | 0.596a | |
MAE | 0.173a | 0.106a | 0.100a | 0.175a | 0.120a | ||
RMSE | 0.221a | 0.166a | 0.151a | 0.266a | 0.196a | ||
RAE | 0.987a | 0.606a | 0.572a | 1.002a | 0.683a | ||
RRSE | 0.995a | 0.748a | 0.681a | 1.198a | 0.883a | ||
Median of nearby points | CC | 0.106a | 0.666a | 0.740a | 0.264a | 0.553 | |
MAE | 0.173a | 0.107a | 0.100a | 0.177a | 0.127 | ||
RMSE | 0.221a | 0.166a | 0.151a | 0.266a | 0.207 | ||
RAE | 0.987a | 0.611a | 0.571a | 1.013a | 0.723 | ||
RRSE | 0.995a | 0.747a | 0.677a | 1.195a | 0.932 | ||
Mean of nearby points | CC | 0.1059a | 0.667a | 0.745 ab | 0.249a | 0.540a | |
MAE | 0.173a | 0.107a | 0.099 ab | 0.179a | 0.129a | ||
RMSE | 0.221a | 0.166a | 0.149 ab | 0.268a | 0.214a | ||
RAE | 0.987a | 0.611a | 0.565 ab | 1.025a | 0.735a | ||
RRSE | 0.995a | 0.747a | 0.672 ab | 1.207a | 0.962a | ||
Regression | CC | 0.107a | 0.663a | 0.739a | 0.242a | 0.559a | |
MAE | 0.172a | 0.106a | 0.101a | 0.179a | 0.126a | ||
RMSE | 0.221a | 0.167a | 0.151a | 0.268a | 0.200a | ||
RAE | 0.987a | 0.610a | 0.581a | 1.027a | 0.723a | ||
RRSE | 0.994a | 0.752a | 0.678a | 1.207a | 0.900a |
a denotes after variable selection with enhancing performance; b denotes the best performance among 5 models after variable selection.