Table 1.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Euthanasia Methods for Zebrafish
Advantages | Disadvantages | |
---|---|---|
Concussion/percussive blow to the head | Fast No residues Simple device |
Uncertain performance Infeasible to study the brain Not appropriate for zebrafish due to their small size Not applicable in embryos or larvae |
Electrical stunning | Rapid and reliable | No adequate methods and devices available for zebrafish |
Muscle tissue potentially damaged by contortion | ||
Not applicable in embryos or larvae | ||
Anesthetic overdose | Extensive experience available Many substances to choose from |
Aversive reaction of animals (stress reactions) to virtually all tested substances |
Chemical contamination (potential chronic exposure) Environmental protection Impact on experiments Personnel safety | ||
Necessitates increased cleaning due to chemical residues (oily properties) increasing costs | ||
Effect/results slower than with other methods | ||
Difficult procurement and disposure for controlled substances | ||
Low effectiveness in embryos and larvae | ||
Rapid cooling | Fastest procedure (seconds) | Not suitable for surgical interventions Might not be effective with all fish species, in particular larger species or nontropical species Not reliable as singular method in embryos |
Brief stress period | ||
Reliable (no recovery of vital functions) | ||
No chemical contamination (environment, personnel, animal, experimental safety) | ||
Safe to personnel | ||
Simple procurement and disposal |