Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Am J Community Psychol. 2017 Nov 20;60(3-4):391–397. doi: 10.1002/ajcp.12184

Table 1.

Risks and Benefits Considered Across Levels of Analysis

Risks Benefits
Individual
  • Individual-level privacy violation

  • Distress

  • Violation of right to freely participate (i.e., coercion)

  • Violation of right to decide whether one’s personal information is used in research (i.e., secondary subjects concerns)

  • Individual-level tangible incentive (e.g., money, class credit)

  • Individual-level intangible incentive (e.g., increased understanding of research process, satisfaction of contributing to broader knowledge)

Group
  • Group-level privacy violation (e.g., identifiability of group to consumers of research), resulting in harm to nonparticipants’ relationships, or decreased group cohesion, reduced trust of researchers/interventionists

  • Findings leveraged against group

  • Group members participate but group does not receive tangible incentive

  • Group-level tangible incentive (e.g., money)

  • Group-level intangible incentive (e.g., recognition from system for having participated)

System
  • Findings leveraged against system

  • Findings fail to reflect marginalized groups within system

  • System recognized for contributing to broader knowledge

Society
  • Failure to contribute to knowledge on social problem

  • Failure to ameliorate social problem

  • Contribution to broader knowledge

  • Amelioration of social problem