Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 15;12(12):e0188941. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0188941

Table 6. ILI prediction results for 31 geolocations estimated using MAPE for nowcasting (this week) and forecasting (one and two weeks).

Locations with min and max MAPE scores are underlined.

This Week One Week Two Weeks
ILI SM ILI + SM ILI SM ILI + SM ILI SM ILI + SM
L14 16.81 15.10 18.18 20.90 23.94 11.55 27.46 28.29 13.18
i2 10.88 13.44 11.65 12.39 13.89 12.01 16.24 14.12 12.43
L3 12.96 15.53 17.25 18.15 39.67 12.94 15.89 35.76 26.80
L27 16.75 16.51 9.97 21.59 22.42 12.57 25.47 26.52 14.12
L20 20.13 19.79 17.09 29.51 23.78 27.39 26.68 24.31 17.57
i25 30.92 25.12 19.34 31.88 22.35 27.48 34.77 26.60 34.70
L28 14.36 12.68 11.53 18.71 27.42 14.62 20.84 29.87 13.45
L11 12.30 18.00 10.92 16.48 28.22 16.91 22.27 21.82 22.23
L25 11.43 21.08 6.95 16.95 30.92 8.89 16.39 29.59 12.55
L10 12.34 18.22 17.51 14.37 18.05 18.48 18.80 27.00 16.76
L4 12.34 18.66 10.25 17.38 22.39 17.88 17.83 20.84 19.20
L29 13.87 19.83 12.53 16.13 19.64 14.24 21.39 24.57 21.02
L0 10.37 14.81 9.14 11.74 13.84 10.27 13.58 17.89 13.65
L23 14.67 26.99 11.86 19.32 35.27 17.73 23.86 30.57 22.67
L12 13.96 33.73 15.29 26.28 45.55 30.91 40.91 72.21 42.30
L30 17.50 26.37 16.67 25.96 32.82 19.66 25.14 34.83 29.43
L33 12.30 17.38 10.11 19.34 21.05 12.80 18.93 18.90 15.74
L15 21.32 37.07 18.22 25.91 41.65 33.94 39.65 69.70 38.24
L13 15.57 23.49 14.71 20.10 32.74 23.18 21.90 36.80 26.06
L31 14.17 35.02 12.48 20.84 40.45 21.08 21.39 34.41 25.80
i3 19.67 24.88 22.49 24.34 26.31 25.57 19.61 26.24 28.90
L32 16.25 38.89 20.99 23.80 39.49 27.12 29.24 63.26 36.96
L22 16.36 34.31 13.33 25.30 34.82 27.52 31.78 44.60 37.27
L21 17.50 37.72 16.46 32.36 30.88 29.58 34.16 46.03 38.12
i27 16.16 26.30 17.97 19.03 24.76 19.11 21.96 27.60 22.09
L34 15.74 17.38 9.45 20.99 21.37 13.97 26.00 21.76 17.22
L37 17.63 21.67 16.91 22.82 24.61 18.93 26.28 23.20 21.69
L16 15.08 21.89 13.42 16.89 20.46 16.00 19.14 23.54 18.39
i20 17.08 41.50 28.70 24.68 42.83 29.66 25.63 45.92 39.26
L19 15.99 35.74 19.52 23.39 35.40 22.09 25.66 36.79 28.04
i17 29.39 56.58 31.59 46.21 59.07 47.09 53.29 63.47 55.70
Mean 16.19 25.34 15.56 22.06 29.55 20.68 25.23 33.77 25.21