Table 3.
Subject | Citation | Mutations | Age, gender | Age at onset | Clinical phenotype | Seizures | MRI and neuropathological findings | OXPHOS activity | Functional proof of pathogenicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||||
1 | Shamseldin et al. | Y144C homozygous |
22 months (deceased) F | 35 days | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental delay | Myoclonic epilepsy Refractory |
Severe cortical atrophy, abnormal signal intensities in putamen and nucleus caudatus (at 1.5 years) | Skeletal muscle: scattered fibers with intense NADH and SDH activity, no ragged red fibers or COX negative fibers | Yes (Elo et al.) |
2 | Shamseldin et al. | Y144C homozygous |
< 3 months (deceased) M | / | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental delay | Myoclonic epilepsy Refractory |
ND | ND | Yes (Elo et al.) |
3 | Shamseldin et al. | Y144C homozygous |
< 3 months (deceased) M | / | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental arrest | Myoclonic epilepsy Refractory |
ND | ND | Yes (Elo et al.) |
4 | Elo et al. | I329T D391V |
8 months (deceased) F | 2 days | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental arrest, | Myoclonic epilepsy, Multifocal seizures, Refractory |
Severe central and cortical atrophy, slight bilateral signal abnormalities in putamina (at 3 m) Autopsy: microcephaly, almost total degeneration of frontal cortex, severe atrophy of hippocampus, basal ganglia and cerebellar cortex, Alpers syndrome |
Severe complex IV deficiency in brain and skeletal muscle, Partial complex I deficiency in brain, No deficiency in cultured skin fibroblasts |
Yes |
5 | Elo et al. | I329T D391V |
21 months (deceased) F | 4 days | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental delay, multiorgan failure | Refractory | ND | ND | Yes |
6 | Almalki et al. | D325Y microdeletion |
30 months M |
6 months | Early onset epilepsy, developmental delay | Infantile spasms, focal seizures, epilepsia partialis continua, prolonged seizures Refractory |
Symmetrical subcortical white matter lesions. Thinning of corpus callosum | Complex IV deficiency in skeletal muscle and myoblast cell lines, Normal activities in cultured skin fibroblasts |
Yes |
7 | Walker et al. | P85A H135D |
15 years (deceased) F |
/ | Infantile onset motor and speech delay, refractory epilepsy, progressive neurological deterioration | Generalized tonic-clonic, focal seizures, epilepsia partialis continua, recurrent status epilepticus | Extensive signal abnormalities in left caudate, cortex and cerebellum Autopsy: almost total degeneration of occipital and frontal cortex, spongiform change in right thalamus, Alpers syndrome |
No ragged-red fibers, no COX negative fibers, polarographic analysis: normal activities complex I-IV | Yes |
8 | Raviglione et al. | R386G microdeletion |
3 years M |
3 months | Early-onset epilepsy, axial hypotonia, developmental delay, strabismus, nystagmus, impaired visual fixation | Infantile spasms (3 months) Seizure free (20 months) |
Microcephaly, severe brain atrophy, hyperintensity of T2 signal abnormalities in hemispheric white matter and dentate nuclei | In cultured skin fibroblasts: complex I 34% and complex IV 37% residual activity | No |
9 | Cho et al. | G309S homozygous |
3 years M |
3 months | Early-onset epilepsy, poor head control (11 months), severe motor delay, spastic legs, brisk deep tendon reflexes | Generalized tonic-clonic, myoclonic, status epilepticus | Diffuse brain atrophy | ND | No |
10 | Cho et al. | G309S homozygous |
17 months F |
4 months | Early-onset epilepsy, motor developmental delay | Myoclonic at right hand, generalized tonic-clonic, status epilepticus, Refractory |
Thin corpus callosum and diffuse brain atrophy | ND | No |
11 | Cho et al. | G309S homozygous |
8 months (deceased) M | 4 months | Early-onset epilepsy | Infantile spasms, ·status epilepticus | Mild brain atrophy | ND | No |
12 | Cho et al. | G309S homozygous |
4 months (deceased) F | 3 months | Early-onset epilepsy, developmental delay | Generalized tonic–clonic, focal clonic, hemiclonic | Mild brain atrophy | ND | No |
| |||||||||
13 | Vernon et al. | R419C microdeletion | 13 years M |
First weeks | Globally delayed, truncal hypotonia, scoliosis, ptosis, Dorsal rhizotomy surgery at 5 years of age |
Complications in neonatal period, seizures only in the neonatal period | Two foci of signal abnormalities in periventricular and deep white matter of right posterior frontal lobe (13 years) | ND | No |
14 | Vernon et al. | R419C microdeletion |
5 years F |
2 months | Globally delayed, strabismus, truncal hypotonia, bilateral equinovarus, brisk deep tendon reflexes, intention tremor, dysarthric speech | One seizure at 2 months of age | Normal (at 3 years) | ND | No |
15 | Yang et al. | D142Y homozygous |
41 years F |
2 years | Progressive limb spasticity, pyramidal weakness, hyperreflexia, extensor plantar reflexes, scissors gait | No seizures | Normal | ND | Yes |
16 | Yang et al. | D142Y homozygous |
30 years M |
1 year | Same phenotype as 15 | No seizures | Normal | ND | Yes |
17 | Yang et al. | D142Y homozygous |
26 years F |
5 years | Same phenotype as 15 | No seizures | Normal | ND | Yes |
18 | Yang et al. | D142Y homozygous |
23 years F |
3 years | Same phenotype as 15 | No seizures | Normal | ND | Yes |
19 | Proband 1 | A154V P361L |
19 years M |
6 months | Developmental delay, spastic paraplegia, neurogenic bladder | Mild seizures only between 15 and 30 months of age | Signal abnormalities in anterior parts of mesencephalon Diffuse brain atrophy |
Complex IV deficiency in skeletal muscle and cultured skin fibroblasts | Yes |
20 | Proband 2 | V174del P361L |
15 years F |
10 months | Delayed motor development, spastic paraplegia | No seizures | Signal abnormalities in tegmentum and periaqueductal grey matter Mild progressive cerebellar atrophy |
Complex I deficiency and low activity of complex IV in cultured skin fibroblasts Normal activities in skeletal muscle |
Yes |