Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Cancer Res. 2017 Sep 1;23(17):4980–4991. doi: 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-16-3064

Table 2.

Summary of recommendations

Nonclinical studies
  • -

    Demonstrate proof-of-principle: target engagement and activity, synergistic or additive effect at tolerable and achievable doses.

  • -

    Characterize PK and PD profile of individual drugs and the combination.

  • -

    Identify optimal concentrations of each drug to inform clinical dose selection.

  • -

    Explore potential biomarkers which can later be refined clinically.

  • -

    Set pre-determined benchmarks defining success prior to considering clinical testing.

  • -

    Develop validated immuno-competent animal models.

  • -

    Develop models of putative mechanisms of resistance.

  • -

    Use multiple models where practicable.

Early phase trials: combination selection and overall goals
  • -

    Focus on populations with unmet need, e.g. PD-1 blockade-refractory patients.

  • -

    Sound biological rationale is a prerequisite for starting clinical development.

  • -

    Combination therapy should offer significant therapeutic advantage over monotherapy with manageable toxicity.

  • -

    Set clearly-defined clinical development plan from the outset and pre-determined decision rules with criteria to define success or failure.

  • -

    Combine best-in-class agents.

  • -

    Industry and academic collaboration vital to minimize duplication of investigational studies and resources.

Early phase clinical trial design
  • -

    Trial design features including method of dose escalation and endpoints, should be carefully considered based on nonclinical or single agent clinical data, tumor and patient characteristics, and objectives.

  • -

    Novel trial designs, including model-based designs, should be strongly considered.

  • -

    Parallel biomarker development studies encouraged to assess mechanisms of resistance and response, PK/PD endpoints and to identify predictive biomarkers.

  • -

    Trial designs aimed at accelerating the development process such as seamless designs with expansion cohorts in phase I may be appropriate for highly efficacious agents and ideally should be implemented in concert with FDA expedited programs to protect patient safety and purpose-fit efforts (112,113).

PD-1, programmed death 1; PK, pharmacokinetic; PD, pharmacodynamic.