Table 2.
Participant ID | Reported ERa | Medical record ER | Reported stagea | Medical record stage | Reported HER2a | Medical record HER2 | Reported gradea | Medical record grade | Incomplete/missed treatment(s)?b | Socioeconomic factors |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DFCI participants | ||||||||||
1 | Positive | Positive | 2 | 2 | Negative | Negative | 3 | 1–2 | Stopped hormonal therapy prematurely, concerns about potential side effects | Black race |
Managed care Plan | ||||||||||
Retired | ||||||||||
Some college | ||||||||||
Money for bills, little to spare | ||||||||||
2 | Unsure; “the desirable one” | Positive | 1 | 2 | Negative | Negative | 1 | 2 | Reports taking hormonal therapy “sometimes every other day” | White race |
Dual Medicare/Medicaid | ||||||||||
Disabled | ||||||||||
College graduate | ||||||||||
Difficulty paying bills | ||||||||||
3 | Negative | Negative | 2 | 2 | Negative | Negative | 3 | 3 | Missed radiation and chemotherapy treatments because of transportation and childcare issues | Black race |
Medicaid | ||||||||||
Disabled | ||||||||||
College degree | ||||||||||
Difficulty paying bills | ||||||||||
4 | Positive | Positive | 1 | 1 | Positive | Positive | 3 | 3 | Stopped hormonal therapy prematurely; also declined some infusional therapy for side effects | White race |
Commercial insurance | ||||||||||
Unemployed | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, has enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
5 | Positive | Positive | 2 | 2 | Positive | Positive | Don't know | 2 | Not applicable—Chemotherapy delayed for neuropathy by provider-patient choice | White race |
Commercial insurance | ||||||||||
Unemployed | ||||||||||
College degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
6 | Negative | Negative | 1 | 1 | Negative | Negative | Don't know | 3 | No | Asian race |
Medicaid | ||||||||||
Unemployed | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
Enough money for bills but only because you cut back | ||||||||||
7 | Positive | Positive | 1 then 4 | 1 then 4 | Negative | Equivocal and negative | Low/medium then high | 3 | Not applicable— Cancer metastasized and she was taken off her therapy |
White race |
Medicaid | ||||||||||
Employed full time | ||||||||||
College graduate | ||||||||||
Money for bills, little spare to buy extra | ||||||||||
8 | Positive | Positive | 3 | 1 | Negative | Negative | 2 | 2 | Not applicable—Stopped hormonal therapy to get pregnant | White |
Commercial insurance | ||||||||||
Stay home mom and occasional work | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
9 | Don't know | Positive | 3 (but unsure) | 3 | Don't know | Positive | 3B | 3 (counted as correct) | Missed radiation and chemotherapy for transportation issues | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Employed full-time | ||||||||||
Less than high school diploma | ||||||||||
Difficulty paying bills | ||||||||||
10 | Positive | Positive | 3 | 2 | Positive | Positive | Don't know | 3 | Missed some radiation treatments because she “was tired of it.” | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Employed full time | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
17 | Positive | Positive | 4 | 4 (treating for cure) | Positive | Positive | Don't know | 3 on biopsy, 1 on mastectomy | No | White |
Managed Care Plan | ||||||||||
On medical leave | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
18 | Don't know | Negative | Between 1 and 2 | 2 but had path CR—counted as correct | Don't know | Negative | Don't know | 3 | No | White, Hispanic |
Medicaid | ||||||||||
Homemaker | ||||||||||
Less than high school diploma | ||||||||||
Money for bills, little to spare | ||||||||||
CUMC participants | ||||||||||
11 | Positive | Positive | Between 1 and 2 | 2 | Don't know | Negative | Don't know | 1 | No | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Retired | ||||||||||
College graduate | ||||||||||
Enough money for bills but only because you cut back | ||||||||||
12 | Positive | Positive | 3 then 4 (unsure) | Stage 2 | Positive | Negative | Don't know | 2 | No | White race |
Managed Care Plan | ||||||||||
Employed full time | ||||||||||
Some college | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
13 | Positive | Positive | 2 | 2 | Negative | Negative | Don't know | 3 | Not applicable—Reported switches in hormonal therapy for side effects but good compliance | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Employed full time | ||||||||||
Some college | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
14 | Don't know | Not available | 1 | Not available | Don't know | Not available | Don't know | Not available | No | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Retired | ||||||||||
Some college | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
15 | Positive | Positive | 1 | 1 | Negative | Negative | 1 | 1 | Declined the recommended chemotherapy and hormonal therapy and opted to “make lifestyle changes instead” | White race |
Medicare | ||||||||||
Retired | ||||||||||
Advanced degree | ||||||||||
After paying bills, enough to buy things you want | ||||||||||
16 | Unsure; positive? | Positive | Between 2 and 3 | 2 | Negative | Negative | Don't know | 3 | No | White race, Hispanic |
Medicaid | ||||||||||
Employed full time | ||||||||||
Some college | ||||||||||
Difficulty paying bills | ||||||||||
Totals (for 17 with records available) | 3/17 (18% did not know ER status) | 4/17 (24% did not know stage) | 3/17 did not know HER2 (18%) | 13/17 did not know grade (71%) | Seven patients reported not starting, stopping, or missing treatments because of reasons other than their provider stopping treatment for toxicity or metastatic disease. Two of these patients reported issues with more than one component of therapy. One additional patient came off therapy to attempt pregnancy. | See Table 1 |
“Reported” = reported by the participant (bolded results are inconsistent with medical record review).
Not applicable = participant stopped/missed therapy for medical reasons and/or because of provider intervention.
CUMC, Columbia University Medical Center; DFCI, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute; ER, estrogen receptor; HER2, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2.