Table 1.
Summary of Key Dependent Variables in Animal Studies Evaluating Phytochemicals as a Therapeutic Intervention after TBI
Compound/Study | Species | Timing of treatment | No. Treatments | Edema | Oxidative stress | Inflammation | Cell loss | Lesion volume | Modified neuroscore | Morris Water Maze |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Allicin | ||||||||||
Chen et al.63 | ? rats | Post | Single | + | + | + | TUNEL + | + | + | |
Apocyn | ||||||||||
Choi et al.45 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | + | FJB + | ||||
Zhang et al.46 | CD-1 mice | Pre/post | Single | + | + | Cresyl + | ||||
Song et al.67 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | + | + | ||||
Ferreira et al.69 | Swiss mice | Pre/post | Multiple | − | + | + | + | + | ||
Loane et al.68 | C57 mice | Post | Single | + | + | + | + | |||
Lu et al.66 | ICR mice | Pre | Single | + | TUNEL + | + | ||||
Baicalein | ||||||||||
Chen et al.71 | SD rats | Post | Single/multiple | + | FJB + | + | + | |||
Wang et al.72 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | TUNEL + | + | |||
Caffeic acid | ||||||||||
Kerman et al.75 | SD rats | Post | Single | + | ||||||
Zhao et al.76 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | Cresyl − | + | + | − | |||
Caffeine | ||||||||||
Al Moutaery el al.78 | Wistar rats | Pre | Single | − | − | TUNEL − | − | |||
Dash et al.81 | SD rats | Post | Single | + | − | − | ||||
Li et al.80 | Kunming mice | Pre | Single | + | + | TUNEL + | − | |||
Lusardi et al.79 | SD rats | Post | Single | − | + | |||||
Cocaine | ||||||||||
Muir and Ellis82 | SD rats | Pre | Single | |||||||
Muir et al.83 | SD rats | Pre | Single | − | − | |||||
Colchicine | ||||||||||
Gahm et al.89 | SD rats | Post | − | FJB + | ||||||
TUNEL − | ||||||||||
Coumarin | ||||||||||
He et al.91 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | + | Cresyl − | + | + | ||
TUNEL + | ||||||||||
Crocin | ||||||||||
Wang et al.92 | C57Bl6 mice | Pre | Single | + | + | TUNEL + | + | |||
Curcumin | ||||||||||
Wu et al.97 | SD rats | Pre | Diet | + | + | |||||
Sharma et al.96 | SD rats | Pre | Diet | |||||||
Sharma et al.95 | SD rats | Post | Diet | + | + | |||||
Wu et al.98 | SD rats | Post | Diet | + | + | + | ||||
Laird et al.100 | CD-1 mice | Pre/post | Single | + | + | − | + | |||
Samini et al.99 | Wistar rats | Pre | Multiple | + | + | + | ||||
Zu et al.101 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Single | + | + | FJB + | + | |||
TUNEL + | ||||||||||
7,8-dihydroxyflavone | ||||||||||
Wu et al.103 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Multiple | + | FJB + | + | − | |||
TUNEL + | ||||||||||
Chen et al.104 | C57Bl6 mice | Pre | Single | FJB + | ||||||
Zhao et al.105 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Multiple | − | + | + | ||||
Agrawal et al.108 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | ||||||
Zhao et al.106 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Multiple | |||||||
Alder et al.107 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Single | FJB + | − | − | ||||
Ellagic acid | ||||||||||
Farbood et al.110 | Wistar rats | Pre | Multiple | + | + | |||||
Epigallocatechin gallate | ||||||||||
Itoh et al.111 | Wistar rats | Pre | Diet | + | NeuN + | + | ||||
Itoh et al.112 | Wistar rats | Pre | Diet | + | ||||||
Itoh et al.113 | Wistar rats | Pre/post | Diet | + | Pre + | |||||
Post − | ||||||||||
Formononetin | ||||||||||
Li et al.114 | Wistar rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | + | + | |||
Gallic acid | ||||||||||
Sarkaki et al.115 | Wistar rats | Pre | Multiple | + | + | |||||
Genistein | ||||||||||
Hong et al.116 | SD rats | Post | ? | |||||||
Soltani et al.117 | Wistar rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | |||||
Ginkgo biloba | ||||||||||
Hoffman and Stein120 | SD rats | Pre/post | Multiple | Thionin + | + | + | ||||
Menku et al.121 | Swiss rats | Post | Multiple | − | + | |||||
Yu et al.122 | Wistar rats | Post | Multiple | + | TUNEL + | |||||
Ginseng | ||||||||||
Ji et al.123 | SD rats | Post | Single | TUNEL − | + | |||||
Xia et al.124 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | + | TUNEL + | − | + | |
Kumar et al.126 | Wistar rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | + | ||||
Chen et al.125 | Wistar rats | Post | Single | + | + | |||||
Hydroxysafflor yellow A | ||||||||||
Bie et al.127 | SD rats | Pre | Multiple | + | TUNEL + | |||||
Lovastatin | ||||||||||
Chen et al.128 | SD rats | Pre | Multiple | + | FJB + | + | + | |||
Luteolin | ||||||||||
Xu et al.129 | ICR mice | Post | Single | + | + | TUNEL + | + | |||
Xu et al.130 | ICR mice | Post | Single | + | + | FJB + | + | |||
Sawmiller et al.131 | Tg2576 mice | Pre | Multiple | |||||||
Cordaro et al.132 | CD-1 mice | Post | Single | + | + | + | H&E + | + | ||
Morphine | ||||||||||
Robinson et al.138 | SD rats | Pre | Single | |||||||
Hayes et al.140 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | ||||||
Lyeth et al.139 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | ||||||
Statler et al.141 | SD rats | Post | Single | FJB − | + | − | − | |||
Zohar et al.142 | ICR mice | Post | Single | + | ||||||
Naringin | ||||||||||
Cui et al.144 | Wistar rats | Pre/post | Multiple | + | + | + | + | |||
Nicotine | ||||||||||
Verbois et al.145 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | ||||||
Verbois et al.146 | SD rats | Pre/post | Multiple | − | Pre − | |||||
Post + | ||||||||||
Shin et al.147 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | |||||||
Nitidine | ||||||||||
Yuan et al.148 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Single | + | TUNEL + | |||||
Puerarin | ||||||||||
Wang et al.149 | SD rats | Pre | Single | + | + | FJB + | ||||
Pycnogenol | ||||||||||
Scheff et al.150 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | |||||
Ansari et al.151 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | ||||||
Norris et al.152 | SD rats | Post | Single | |||||||
Scheff and Roberts153 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | FJB − | + | − | ||||
Quercetin | ||||||||||
Schultke et al.154 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | ||||||
Yang et al.155 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | TUNEL + | + | |||
Resveratrol | ||||||||||
Ates et al.159 | Wistar rats | Post | Single | + | + | + | ||||
Singleton et al.161 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | Cresyl + | + | + | + | |||
Gatson et al.160 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Multiple | + | ||||||
Lin et al.162 | SD rats | Post | Single | + | ||||||
Feng et al.163 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | + | + | |||
Feng et al.164 | SD rats | Post | Multiple | + | + | + | ||||
Rutin | ||||||||||
Kumar et al.167 | Wistar rats | Post | Diet | + | + | + | ||||
Salvianolic acid B | ||||||||||
Chen et al.168 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Single | + | + | + | + | + | ||
Triptolide | ||||||||||
Lee et al.170 | SD rats | Post | Single | + | + | TUNEL + | + | + | ||
Wogonin | ||||||||||
Chen et al.171 | C57Bl6 mice | Post | Single | + | + | FJB + | + | + | ||
TUNEL + |
+, positive significant effect; −, no significant positive effect or change; Cresyl (cresyl violet staining); Diet (compound delivered in the diet); FJB (Fluoro-jade staining); H&E (hematoxylin and eosin staining); Multiple (compound given multiple times or continuously); Pre (compound administered prior to injury); Post (compound administered after injury); SD (Sprague Dawley); Single (compound administered only once); Thionin (thionin staining); TUNEL, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) dUTP nick-end labeling (staining for apoptosis).