Skip to main content
. 2017 Nov 10;208(1):349–364. doi: 10.1534/genetics.117.300498

Table 4. RRMs were used to test for I*E and G*E for each of our six traits, plus annual fitness.

Trait Model Variance components χ2 d.f. P value
Body weight 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 3.16 2 0.206
3.3 VA + VPE 40.36 1 < 0.001
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 2.92 2 0.232
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 5.00 2 0.082
Hind leg length 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 0.00 2 0.999
3.3 VA + VPE 49.22 1 < 0.001
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 0.00 2 0.999
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 0.00 2 0.999
Strongyle FEC 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 0.66 2 0.719
3.3 VA + VPE 5.50 1 0.019
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 0.54 2 0.763
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 0.86 2 0.651
Horn length 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 33.68 2 < 0.001
3.3 VA + VPE 10.80 1 0.005
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 31.52 2 < 0.001
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 5.82 2 0.054
Horn growth 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 0.00 2 0.999
3.3 VA + VPE 1.64 1 0.200
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 0.00 2 0.999
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 0.00 2 0.999
Testicular circumference 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 22.52 2 < 0.001
3.3 VA + VPE 9.90 1 0.002
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 19.66 2 < 0.001
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 2.80 2 0.247
Annual fitness 3.1 ID
3.2 ID + ID*PD 6.34 2 0.042
3.3 VA + VPE 0.74 1 0.390
3.4 VA + VPE + ID*PD 6.22 2 0.045
3.5 VA + VPE + VPE*PD + VA*PD 3.12 2 0.210

For each model, the variance components structure of the individual and/or additive genetic variance component is given, where ID, individual identity; VA, additive genetic variance; VPE, permanent environment variance; and PD, population density. Other details of model structure are provided in the Materials and Methods. Also shown are the χ2 statistics and P-values associated with the likelihood ratio test used to compare the model in question with a model omitting the term in question. FEC, fecal egg count.