Table 1. Recommendation and evidence rating (GRADE system).
Assessment of evidence level | Strength of recommendation | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study design | Initial quality of evidence | Factors that downgrade quality of evidence | Factors that upgrade quality of evidence | Quality of evidence | |
Randomized study | High ⇨ | Risk of bias Serious: −1 Very serious: −2 |
Effect size Large: +1 Very large: +2 |
High: 4 Moderate: 3 Low: 2 Very low: 1 |
Strong: Benefits clearly outweigh harm, or vice versa Weak: All cases other than “strong” recommendation |
Inconsistency Serious: −1 Very serious: −2 |
Positive relation Present: +1 |
||||
Observational study | Low ⇨ | Indirectness Serious: −1 Very serious: −2 |
Confounding variables Increased confidence of effect estimation: +1 |
||
Imprecision Serious: −1 Very serious: −2 |
|||||
Publication bias Strongly suspected: −1 |