Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 26;49(4):326–352. doi: 10.3947/ic.2017.49.4.326

Table 1. Recommendation and evidence rating (GRADE system).

Assessment of evidence level Strength of recommendation
Study design Initial quality of evidence Factors that downgrade quality of evidence Factors that upgrade quality of evidence Quality of evidence
Randomized study High ⇨ Risk of bias
 Serious: −1
 Very serious: −2
Effect size
 Large: +1
 Very large: +2
High: 4
Moderate: 3
Low: 2
Very low: 1
Strong: Benefits clearly outweigh harm, or vice versa
Weak: All cases other than “strong” recommendation
Inconsistency
 Serious: −1
 Very serious: −2
Positive relation
 Present: +1
Observational study Low ⇨ Indirectness
 Serious: −1
 Very serious: −2
Confounding variables
 Increased confidence of effect estimation: +1
Imprecision
 Serious: −1
 Very serious: −2
Publication bias
 Strongly suspected: −1