Table 3.
Author | Study details | Participant characteristics | ||||
Year | Country | Design, setting | Sample size | Sample characteristics | Control group | |
Calvert et al 22 | 2012 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=2) | 143 | Median age: IG=63, CG=62; male: IG=66%, CG=61%; White: IG=51%, CG=51% | Usual care: routine discharge counselling and discharge summary sent to community physician. |
Cossette et al 23 | 2012 | Canada | RCT, single site | 242 | Mean age: IG=59, CG=59; male: IG=81%, CG=90% | Usual care: received standard predischarge care. Encouraged to use regular healthcare resources postdischarge. |
Costa e Silva et al 24 | 2008 | Brazil | RCT, single site | 153 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=59; male: IG=63%, CG=64% | Usual care: standard outpatient follow-up with a cardiologist. |
Du et al 25 | 2016 | China | RCT, single site | 979 | Mean age: IG=60, CG=62; male: IG=73%, CG=72% | Usual care: standard follow-up with research nurse. |
Giallauria et al 26 | 2009 | Italy | RCT, single site | 52 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=57; male: IG=85%, CG=85% | Usual care: following standard 3-month cardiac rehab, patients were discharged with usual routine recommendations and were seen only at the 12-month and 24-month follow-up. |
Giannuzzi et al 27 | 2008 | Italy | RCT, multi-site (n=78) | 3241 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=58; male: IG=86%, CG=87% | Usual care: a letter sent to the family physician recommending secondary prevention goals followed by standard cardiac rehab and follow-up. |
Gould28 | 2011 | USA | RCT, single site | 129 | NR | Usual care: patients received routine discharge materials and usual care. |
Gujral et al 29 | 2014 | Australia | RCT, single site | 200 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=60; male: IG=77%, CG=80% | Usual care: medication beliefs not communicated to their community pharmacist. The community pharmacists were asked to provide the patient with usual care when they collected their prescription medications. |
Ho et al 30 | 2014 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=4) | 253 | Mean age: IG=64, CG=64; male: IG=98%, CG=98%; White: IG=82%, CG=75% | Usual care: patients received standard ACS hospital discharge instructions, a discharge medication list and educational information about cardiac medications. A 12-month clinic visit was scheduled. |
Jalal et al 32 | 2016 | UK | RCT, single site | 71 | Mean age=NR; male=76% | Usual care: following predischarge counselling from the hospital pharmacist, patients refilled their prescriptions at their usual pharmacies. |
Jorstad et al 31 | 2013 | Netherlands | RCT, multi-site (n=11) | 733 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=58; male: IG=80%, CG=80% | Usual care: outpatient clinic visits to treating cardiologists and other relevant specialists. Patients were referred to cardiac rehab according to national guidelines. |
Kotowycz et al 33 | 2010 | Canada | RCT, single site | 54 | Mean age: IG=56, CG=55; male: IG=81%, CG=70% | All discharge planning and follow-up were left to the treating physician and nursing team. |
Kronish et al 34 | 2012 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=5) | 177 | Mean age: IG=59, CG=61; male: IG=46%, CG=47% | Usual care: treating physicians notified about their patients’ depressive status. Patients given appropriate care for depressive symptoms. |
Lapointe et al 35 | 2006 | Canada | RCT, single site | 127 | Mean age: IG=58, CG=57; male: IG=89%, CG=78% | Standard follow-up with patients’ regular physician. |
Miller et al 36 | 1988 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=3) | 103 | Mean age=NR (range 30 - 65); male: IG=73%, CG=89%; White: IG=98%, CG=87% | Usual care: all patients had received standard inpatient cardiac rehab. |
Miller et al 37 | 1989 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=3) | 81 | Mean age=54; male=81% | Usual care: all patients had received standard inpatient cardiac rehab. |
Miller et al 38 | 1990 | USA | RCT, multi-site (n=3) | 51 | Mean age=55; male=76% | Usual care: all patients had received standard inpatient cardiac rehab. |
Muñiz et al 39 | 2010 | Spain | RCT, multi-site (n=64) | 1757 | Mean age: IG=62, CG=64; male: IG=78%, CG=76% | Usual care. |
Najafi et al 40 | 2016 | Iran | RCT, single site | 100 | Mean age: IG=59, CG=58; male: IG=54%, CG=38% | Routine care including check-ups with designated physician. |
Polack et al 41 | 2008 | Canada | RCT, single site | 10 | Mean age: IG=59, CG=65; male: IG=80%, CG=100% | Usual care: standard predischarge nurse education. |
Polsook et al 42 | 2016 | Thailand | RCT, single site | 44 | Mean age: IG=61, CG=63; male: IG=86%, CG=86% | Usual care in the cardiac inpatient department that included education about patients’ condition and treatment. |
Redfern et al 44 | 2008 | Australia | RCT, single site | 144 | Mean age: IG=62, CG=67; male: IG=74%, CG=75% | Ongoing conventional care determined by patients’ family physician and cardiologist. |
Redfern et al 43 | 2009 | Australia | RCT, single site | 144 | Mean age: IG=62, CG=67; male: IG=74%, CG=75% | Usual care: received medical treatment, including pharmacotherapy and lifestyle counselling, as determined by their usual doctors. |
Uysal and Ozcan45 | 2015 | Turkey | RCT, multi-site (n=2) | 90 | Mean age=NR (47% between 45-54); male: IG=80%, CG=76% | Received home education kit comprised of brochures about healthy living post-MI. Not provided with telephone counselling and education. |
Xavier et al 46 | 2016 | India | RCT, multi-site (n=14) | 806 | Mean age: IG=56, CG=57; male: IG=82%, CG=83% | Standard care: patients were asked to alert the research team to any hospital visits that they planned. |
Sharma et al 47 | 2016 | India | RCT, single site | 100 | Mean age: IG=57, Con=61; Male total=84% | Usual care. |
Yorio et al 48 | 2008 | USA | RCT, single site | 144 | Median age: IG=56, CG=56; male: IG=67%, CG=57%; White: IG=32%, CG=35% | Usual care: standard postdischarge care that included appointments with a cardiologist and family physician within 3 months. |
Author | Methodological features | |||||
Intention to treat | Follow-up | Adherence as an outcome | Primary outcome | Adherence measurement | Sessions | |
Calvert et al 22 | Not stated | 6 months | Primary | Medication adherence | Self-report; MMAS-4; PDC | 4 |
Cossette et al 23 | Not stated | 6 weeks | Secondary | Cardiac rehab attendance | MMAS-4 | 3 |
Costa e Silva et al 24 | Yes | 6 months | Primary (one of) | Clinical improvement index (including medication adherence) | Self-report | 2 |
Du et al 25 | Not stated | 36 months | Secondary | Mortality and MACE | MMAS-4 | 6 |
Giallauria et al 26 | Not stated | 24 months | Secondary | Cardiopulmonary parameters and cardiovascular risk profile (including medication adherence) | Self-report | 24 |
Giannuzzi et al 27 | Yes | 36 months | Secondary | MACE | Self-report | 11 |
Gould28 | Not stated | 3 days | Primary (one of) | Medication adherence, use of urgent care, patient satisfaction and illness perceptions | MMAS-4 | 1 |
Gujral et al 29 | Not stated | 12 months | Primary (one of) | Medication adherence and treatment beliefs | MARS; MPR | 2 |
Ho et al 30 | Yes | 12 months | Primary | Medication adherence | PDC | 4 |
Jalal et al 32 | Not stated | 6 months | Primary | Medication adherence | MMAS-8 | 1 |
Jorstad et al 31 | Not stated | 12 months | Secondary | Lifestyle and biometric targets | Self-report | 4 |
Kotowycz et al 33 | Yes | 6 weeks | Secondary | MACE | Self-report | 4 |
Kronish et al 34 | Yes | 6 months | Primary (one of) | Adherence to medication, heart healthy diet, regular exercise and smoking cessation | Self-report | NR |
Lapointe et al 35 | Not stated | 18 months | Secondary | LDL-C targets | Prescription refills | NR |
Miller et al 36 | Not stated | 60 days | Primary | MRA | HBS | 3 |
Miller et al 37 | Not stated | 12 months | Primary | MRA | HBS | 3 |
Miller et al 38 | Not stated | 24 months | Primary | MRA | HBS | 3 |
Muñiz et al 39 | Not stated | 6 months | Primary (one of) | Behavioural and clinical targets (including medication adherence) | Self-report | 2 |
Najafi et al 40 | Not stated | 3 months | Primary | Medication adherence | MMAS-8 | 6 |
Polack et al 41 | Not stated | 6 weeks | Primary (one of) | Medication adherence and knowledge retention | MMAS-4 | 2 |
Polsook et al 42 | Not stated | 4 weeks | Primary (one of) | Medication adherence and self-efficacy | Pill count | 14 |
Redfern et al 43 | Yes | 3 months | Secondary | Behavioural and clinical targets | Self-report | 5 |
Redfern et al 44 | Yes | 12 months | Secondary | Behavioural and clinical targets | Self-report | 5 |
Uysal and Ozcan45 | Not stated | 3 months | Primary (one of) | Physical activity, medication adherence, anginal symptoms | MMAS-4 | 3 |
Xavier et al 46 | Yes | 12 months | Primary | Medication adherence | CMAS | 18 |
Sharma et al 47 | Yes | 24 months | Primary | Mediation adherence | CMAS | 10 |
Yorio et al 48 | Not stated | 12 months | Secondary | Improved LDL-C profile | Prescription refills | 1 |
Author | Intervention features | |||
Interventionist | Delivery method | Theoretical basis | Intervention summary | |
Calvert et al 22 | Pharmacist | In person and phone | Not stated | Predischarge counselling covering the importance and purpose of medications and barriers to adherence. Pocket medication card, cheat sheet (tips for remembering) and pillbox also provided. Regular follow-up with community pharmacist to discuss adherence-related issues. |
Cossette et al 23 | Nurse | In person and phone | CS-SRM | Predischarge counselling session: symptom and physical activity management, coherence around illness episode, concerns/worries. Postdischarge counselling sessions: disease management, concerns/worries and intentions about risk factor modification, problem solving. |
Costa e Silva et al 24 | MDT (included nurse) | In person only | Not stated | Transdisciplinary outpatient care provided. Detailed treatment planning and follow-up with nurse, dietitian, endocrinologist and cardiologist. HCPs collaborated to reinforce lifestyle change and formulate a care plan. |
Du et al 25 | Physician (cardiologist) | Phone only | Not stated | Physician-led intensive telephone follow-up over 36 months. Patients provided with additional health education, disease-prevention suggestions and consultations on medication usage. Face-to-face visits were scheduled if necessary. |
Giallauria et al 26 | MDT (included nurse) | In person only | Not stated | Monthly hospital meetings to discuss lifestyle change and engage in exercise training. Received a booklet about lifestyle change and promoting patients’ role in their healthcare. Encouraged family support throughout. |
Giannuzzi et al 27 | MDT (included nurse) | In person only | Not stated | Comprehensive cardiac rehab sessions that included exercise training and lifestyle and risk factor counselling. Encouraged family support throughout. Pharmacological treatments positively recommended to all patients. Received booklet to support lifestyle change and patient empowerment. |
Gould28 | Nurse | Phone only | CS-SRM | Patients received written discharge materials, telephone follow-up by an expert, medication review materials, a medication pocket card and suggested websites. |
Gujral et al 29 | Pharmacist | In person and phone | NCF | Tailored intervention targeting treatment beliefs. Beliefs and attitudes towards treatment elicited using repertory grid technique and then communicated to the community pharmacist. Information used to tailor their discussions with the patient during follow-up. Patient also reviewed monthly by community pharmacist to discuss adherence-related issues. |
Ho et al 30 | Pharmacist | In person and phone | Not stated | Pharmacist-led postdischarge medication reconciliation and follow-up. Predischarge and postdischarge education sessions with pharmacist followed by automated educational voice messages. Use of pill boxes to organise medications. Increased communication between pharmacists and patients’ care team. Automated voice reminders to refill prescriptions. |
Jalal et al 32 | Pharmacist | In person and phone | Not stated | Community pharmacist-led motivational interview aimed at improving protective cardiovascular medicine taking. Consultations were delivered as part of the New Medicine Service or a Medication Usage Review (established UK NHS pharmacy services). |
Jorstad et al 31 | Nurse | In person only | Not stated | Outpatient visits with a nurse: educational sessions targeted lifestyle change and risk factor management. Lifestyle and risk factors reviewed and patients received individual counselling. Medication adherence encouraged and reasons for discontinuation discussed. |
Kotowycz et al 33 | Nurse | In person and phone | Not stated | Nurse-led patient education about the nature and management of their cardiac disease, with a focus on medications and facilitation of discharge planning. |
Kronish et al 34 | Other (problem-solving therapist) | In person only | Not stated | Patients given a choice of either PST and/or pharmacotherapy. Weekly PST sessions were brief, problem focused and designed to augment self-efficacy and address psychosocial issues. Focus also on the initiation of pleasant activities. Patients given choice of different pharmacotherapy. |
Lapointe et al 35 | Nurse | Phone only | Not stated | Patients received postdischarge letter and phone call concerning risk factor education and management. Clinical goals (lipid profile) set and patients received additional intervention from their physician if goals not met. Compliance assessment with pharmacist conducted at 12 and 18 months. |
Miller et al 36 | Nurse | In person only | TRA | Intervention included an assessment (addressing attitudes, beliefs and intentions), problem identification (coping and societal adjustment) and developing a detailed health plan. Spouses were encouraged to participate. |
Miller et al 37 | Nurse | In person only | TRA | Intervention included an assessment (addressing attitudes, beliefs and intentions), problem identification (coping and societal adjustment) and developing a detailed health plan. Spouses were encouraged to participate. |
Miller et al 38 | Nurse | In person only | TRA | Intervention included an assessment (addressing attitudes, beliefs and intentions), problem identification (coping and societal adjustment) and developing a detailed health plan. Spouses were encouraged to participate. |
Muniz et al 39 | Physician | In person only | Not stated | Focused on the patient-provided relationship. Discharge interview included a signed agreement of secondary prevention care plan and comprehensive written material about risk factor management. During a follow-up session, agreement reviewed and adapted if necessary. |
Najafi et al 40 | Researcher (nurse) | Phone only | Not stated | Nurse-led follow-up telephone calls based on lifestyle counselling and education. Agreed behavioural objectives were reviewed and barriers were addressed through problem solving. Family participation was encouraged throughout. |
Polack et al 41 | Pharmacist | In person only | Not stated | Received predischarge pharmacist-led education around the benefits and risks of cardiac medications. Sessions included use of a patient education tool. |
Polsook et al 42 | Researcher (nurse) | In person and phone | Not stated | Comprised a 4-week self-efficacy enhancement program that targeted patients’ motivation to be adherent, skills development and adherence self-monitoring. |
Redfern et al 43 | Other (physiotherapist) | In person and phone | Not stated | Based around risk factor assessment and goal setting. Patients chose their risk factor module and self-committed to a written action plan. Received a resource pack that included information leaflets. Follow-up sessions tested patients’ knowledge of their risk factors. Personal goals were also identified and positive. Risk-lowering behaviour recorded. |
Redfern et al 44 | Other (physiotherapist) | In person and phone | Not stated | Based around risk factor assessment and goal setting. Patients chose their risk factor module and self-committed to a written action plan. Received a resource pack that included information leaflets. Follow-up sessions tested patients’ knowledge of their risk factors. Personal goals were also identified and positive. Risk-lowering behaviour recorded. |
Uysal and Ozcan45 | Researcher (nurse) | In person and phone | Not stated | Individualised education plans around lifestyle and risk factor management. Received access to a computer-based education along with brochures on lifestyle changes post-MI. Telephone counselling during follow-up addressing negative health behaviours, including treatment non-adherence. |
Xavier et al 46 | Other: community health worker | In person and phone | Not stated | Involved personalised counselling to help overcome barriers to adherence and lifestyle modification. Also received an adherence calendar to record medication taking and were asked to complete diaries, which included information about their medications. Family participation encouraged. |
Sharma et al 47 | Other: community health worker | In person and phone | Not stated | Involved personalised counselling to help overcome barriers to adherence and lifestyle modification. Also received an adherence calendar to record medication taking and were asked to complete diaries, which included information about their medications. Family participation encouraged. |
Yorio et al 48 | Nurse or pharmacist | In person only | Not stated | Postdischarge session with nurse or pharmacist. Session included full medication review and titration, risk factor counselling and discussion/referral to cardiac rehab and other HCPs (dietician and/or smoking cessation service). |
ACS, acute coronary syndrome; CG, control group; CMAS, Composite Medication Adherence Score; CS-SRM, Common-Sense Model of Self-Regulation; HBS, Health Behaviour Scale; HCP, healthcare provider; IG, intervention group; LDL-C, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; MACE, major adverse cardiac events; MARS, Medication Adherence Report Scale; MDT, multidisciplinary team; MI, myocardial infarction; MMAS-4, Morisky Medication Adherence Scale (4-item); MMAS-8, Morisky Medication Adherence Scale (8-item); MPR, medication possession ratio; MRA, medical regimen adherence; NCF, necessity concerns framework; NR, not reported; PDC, proportion of days covered; PST, problem-solving therapy; RCT, randomised controlled trial; TRA, theory of reasoned action.