Table 4.
Ghana | Mozambique | Rwanda | Tanzania | Zambia | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Facility-based data collection | Frequency | • CHW time-motion survey: Baseline • Health facility survey: Baseline and midline |
• Patient exit and time-motion survey: Baseline and endline • Health facility survey: Annual service provision assessment and data quality audit |
• Health facility survey: Quarterly | • CHW time-motion survey: Baseline • Health facility survey: Baseline and midline |
• Health facility survey: Baseline, midline, and endline |
Sampling | Time-motion survey: Intervention areas Facility survey: Intervention and comparison areas |
Patient exit & time-motion survey: Intervention and comparison areas Facility survey: 27 purposively selected facilities, intervention area |
All 22 facilities in intervention area | Time-motion survey: Intervention areas Facility survey: Sample of 107 (baseline) and 141 (midline) facilities in intervention & comparison areas |
All intervention and comparison areasa | |
Special studies | Frequency | Qualitative process evaluation | Qualitative process evaluation: endline | Qualitative process evaluation Policy analysis | Qualitative process evaluation | Qualitative process evaluation |
Sampling | Key informant interviews & focus group discussions with district and national health leaders | Key informant interviews with purposively selected stakeholders in intervention area | Key informant interviews with purposively selected local and national health leaders | Key informant interviews & focus group discussions with community, facility and district health leaders | Key informant interviews with facility and district leaders | |
Community Surveys / Demographic Surveillance System | Frequency | Community survey: Baseline & endline Demographic Surveillance system (Navrongo): Semi-annual |
Community survey: Baseline, midline (2 surveys), & endline | Community survey: Baseline & endline | Health and Demographic Surveillance System: Semi-annual | Community survey: Approximately annual |
Sampling | Intervention and comparison areas | Intervention and comparison areas | Intervention and comparison areas | Intervention and comparison areas | Intervention and comparison areas | |
Health Management Information System | Frequency | Monthly facility reports | Monthly facility reports | Monthly facility reports | Monthly CHW activity reports | Monthly facility reports |
Sampling | Full capture for all intervention and control facilities | Full capture for all facilities in intervention area | Full capture for all facilities in intervention area | Full capture for all CHWs in intervention area | Full capture for all facilities in intervention and comparison areas | |
Project Monitoring System | Frequency | Ongoing training, supervision, program and financial reports Ongoing contextual data tracking |
Ongoing training, supervision program and financial reports Ongoing contextual data tracking |
Ongoing training, supervision program and financial reports Ongoing contextual data tracking |
Ongoing training, supervision program and financial reports Ongoing contextual data tracking |
Ongoing training, supervision program and financial reports Ongoing contextual data tracking |
Sampling | Routine activity reports: Intervention area Contextual data: Intervention and comparison areas |
Routine activity reports: Intervention area Contextual data: Intervention and comparison areas |
Routine activity reports: Intervention area Contextual data: Intervention and comparison areas |
Routine activity reports: Intervention area Contextual data: Intervention and comparison areas |
Routine activity reports: Intervention and comparison areas Contextual data: Intervention and comparison areas |
aNote: As Zambia used a stepped-wedge design, intervention and comparison facilities vary over time