Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 21;44(1):114–125. doi: 10.1093/schbul/sbx036

Table 2.

Assessment of Study Quality

Study Ref Unbiased Selection of the Cohort Selection Minimizes Baseline Differences in Prognostic Factors? Sample Size Calculated? Adequate Description of the Cohort? Validated Method for Ascertaining Psychotic Symptoms Validated Method for Ascertaining Loneliness Adequate Handling of Missing Data
Angell et al, 2002 Partial Yes No/not reported Yes Yes No Yes
Badcock et al, 2015 Yes Partial n/a Yes Yes No Yes
Gayer-Anderson et al, 2014 (conference abstract) Not reported Not reported No/not reported Not reported Not reported Not reported Not reported
Giblin et al, 2004 Partial Partial No/not reported Partial Yes Yes Not reported
Lindner et al, 2014 Unclear Not reported No/not reported Partial Yes Yes Not reported
Ludwig et al, 2013 unpublished Partial Yes No/not reported Partial yes Yes Not reported
Meltzer et al, 2013 Yes Yes n/a Yes Partial No No
Roe et al, 2011 Partial n/a (no control group) No/not reported Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sundermann et al, 2014 Partial n/a (no control group) Yes Yes yes No Yes
Stein et al, 2013 Partial No No/not reported Yes Partial Yes Not reported
Switaj et al, 2014 Partial n/a (no control group) No/not reported Partial Yes Yes Not reported
Switaj et al, 2016—in press Not reported Yes No/not reported Not reported Yes Yes Not reported
Tietjen, 1993 Partial No No/not reported Yes Yes Yes Not reported