Table 2.
Study Ref | Unbiased Selection of the Cohort | Selection Minimizes Baseline Differences in Prognostic Factors? | Sample Size Calculated? | Adequate Description of the Cohort? | Validated Method for Ascertaining Psychotic Symptoms | Validated Method for Ascertaining Loneliness | Adequate Handling of Missing Data |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Angell et al, 2002 | Partial | Yes | No/not reported | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Badcock et al, 2015 | Yes | Partial | n/a | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Gayer-Anderson et al, 2014 (conference abstract) | Not reported | Not reported | No/not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
Giblin et al, 2004 | Partial | Partial | No/not reported | Partial | Yes | Yes | Not reported |
Lindner et al, 2014 | Unclear | Not reported | No/not reported | Partial | Yes | Yes | Not reported |
Ludwig et al, 2013 unpublished | Partial | Yes | No/not reported | Partial | yes | Yes | Not reported |
Meltzer et al, 2013 | Yes | Yes | n/a | Yes | Partial | No | No |
Roe et al, 2011 | Partial | n/a (no control group) | No/not reported | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Sundermann et al, 2014 | Partial | n/a (no control group) | Yes | Yes | yes | No | Yes |
Stein et al, 2013 | Partial | No | No/not reported | Yes | Partial | Yes | Not reported |
Switaj et al, 2014 | Partial | n/a (no control group) | No/not reported | Partial | Yes | Yes | Not reported |
Switaj et al, 2016—in press | Not reported | Yes | No/not reported | Not reported | Yes | Yes | Not reported |
Tietjen, 1993 | Partial | No | No/not reported | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not reported |