Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 27;7(12):e014633. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014633

Table 3.

Predictors of quality score for different factors including paper type, week, day, food category, health category, named journalist and article size

Factors predicting article quality score n OR 95% CI OR P value for comparison with ref P value for likelihood ratio test
Paper title: reference category is 40 0.95
The Daily Mail
  The Sun 20 0.80 0.03 to 25.21 0.90
  The Daily Mirror 23 0.60 0.07 to 4.84 0.63
  The Daily Express 30 0.78 0.10 to 5.83 0.81
  The Daily Telegraph 28 0.78 0.16 to 3.88 0.77
Day: reference category is Tuesday 35 <0.01
  Monday 27 3.90 1.09 to 13.92 0.04
  Wednesday 25 3.83 0.31 to 47.20 0.30
  Thursday 25 13.64 0.65 to 287.6 0.09
  Friday 15 6.94 1.02 to 47.19 0.05
  Saturday 14 0.21 0.09 to 0.53 <0.01
Food: reference category is energy 27 0.03
  Alcohol 18 3.72 0.41 to 34.19 0.25
  Fruit and vegetables 25 0.66 0.04 to 11.81 0.78
  High fat and processed foods 21 0.39 0.02 to 8.49 0.55
  Protein and dairy foods 21 4.66 0.36 to 60.27 0.24
  Sugary drinks and confectionery 9 1.56 0.25 to 9.67 0.63
  Other (vitamins and ingredients) 20 0.86 0.06 to 12.17 0.91
Health: reference category is obesity 35 0.03
  Cancer 8 24.30 3.17 to 186.2 <0.01
  CVD 34 11.73 2.69 to 51.24 <0.01
  Type 2 diabetes 17 12.31 1.55 to 98.04 0.02
  Neurological disorders 22 7.18 0.85 to 60.84 0.07
  Life expectancy 10 1.75 0.10 to 30.17 0.70
  Other (respiratory and reproductive) 12 3.61 1.04 to 12.61 0.04
Named journalist: reference category is yes 98 <0.01
  No named journalist 43 0.10 0.01 to 0.84 0.03
Article size: reference category is small 82 0.52
  Medium-sized articles 36 0.92 0.66 to 2.78 0.88
  Large-sized articles 23 2.79 0.66 to 11.75 0.16

CVD, cardiovascular disease.