Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2018 Jan-Feb;6(1):22–29. doi: 10.1016/j.jaip.2017.10.002

Table I.

School Environmental Intervention Studies

Study Population Design Population/School Size Intervention Effectiveness of Intervention
Pilotto et al.76 (2004) Children with asthma from primary schools (mean age 8–9 y; Australia) Randomized control trial 18 schools, 10 control and 8 intervention schools
118 children, intervention group 45, control group 73
Replacement flued gas or electric heaters in schools
  • Reduction in NO2 exposure

  • Reduction in asthma symptoms

Jhun et al.77 (2017) Children with asthma (aged 6–10 y; US) Randomized control trial (Pilot Study) 3 schools, 9 control and 9 intervention classrooms
25 children, intervention group 12, control group 13
Classroom based HEPA air cleaner intervention
  • Reductions in PM2.5 and BC

  • Modest improvement in peak flow, no significant changes in FEV1 and asthma symptoms

Bernstein et al.78 (2005) US Randomized control trial (Pilot Study) Day care A: 8 rooms
Day care B: 6 rooms
Intervention installed in half the rooms of each day care
Dehumidification plus day care room based HEPA air cleaner
  • Lower average dew point from baseline for both day care A and B

  • Reduction in fungal spore counts for day care A only

Lignell et al.79 (2007) Children (aged 7–12 y; Finland) Longitudinal intervention study 1 Moisture damaged school
1 Non-damaged school
Over 2,400 children returned surveys
Damaged school renovated for all identified problems, mechanical exhaust and supply air ventilation system installed
  • 50% reduction in fungal concentrations

  • Modest reduction in respiratory symptoms

Meklin et al.80 (2005) Children (aged 6–17 y, Finland) Longitudinal intervention study 2 Moisture damaged schools
2 Non-damaged schools
Over 1,300 children returned surveys
Damaged schools thoroughly cleaned, repaired, and renovated, mechanical exhaust and supply ventilation system installed
  • Normalization of indoor air fungal concentrations

  • Reduction in respiratory and other symptoms

Karlsson et al.81 (2004) Sweden Intervention study 3 schools, 6 classrooms in total, 3 control and 3 intervention classrooms from each school 1 class of children with no pets, 2 classes of children who changed into special school clothing upon arrival
  • 4-fold to 6-fold lower airborne cat allergen levels in intervention classes compared with control classes

Abbreviations: NO2, nitrogen dioxide; HEPA, high efficiency particulate arrestance; PM2.5, particulate matter 2.5; BC, black carbon; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1 second; US, United States