Table 1.
Summary of studies using LIF for the treatment of dry eye
Reference | Evidence leveli | n | Population | Dose/treatment length | Efficacy
|
Side effects | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
LIF vs control | LIF vs baseline* | ||||||
Semba et al150 | Level 1A Phase II, multicenter, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled study | 230 | Americans ≥18 years old with the following: • Established history of bilateral dry eye • Use or desire to use AT substitute in the past 6 months • Conjunctival redness in any eye • CSS ≥2 in any eye • Schl >1 and <10 in any eye • BCVA ≥0.7 logMAR in both eyes • CAE-induced increase in ICSS >1 point in designated eye • CAE-induced increase in ODS >1 point in designated eye |
LIF 0.1%, 1%, 5% vs vehicle twice daily for 84 days with CAE for 90 minutes at days 14, 42, and 84 of treatment | LIF better: Signs: ICSS (84 days with 1% and 5% LIF), Schl (14 days with 5% LIF) Symptoms: OSDI (14 days in all, 84 days with 1% LIF) VR-OSDI (14 and 84 days with 1% and 5% LIF), VAS (84 days, burning/stinging only) No difference: VAS, TBUT, conjSS, blink rate, ODS |
Symptoms: ODS, VAS-EDS, VAS (photophobia) | • Instillation site irritation • Mild and transient |
| |||||||
Sheppard et al151 | Level 1A Phase III, multicenter, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled study | 588 | Americans ≥18 years old with the following: • Established history of bilateral dry eye • Use or desire to use AT substitute in the past 6 months • Conjunctival redness in any eye • CSS ≥2 in any eye • Schl >1 and <10 in any eye • BCVA ≥0.7 logMAR in both eyes • CAE-induced increase in ICSS ≥1 point in designated eye • Intra-CAE ODS ≥3 or ≥4 if baseline pre-CAE was 3 |
LIF 5% vs vehicle twice daily for 84 days. No CAE during treatment | LIF better: Signs: ICSS (84 days), SCSS (84 days), CSS (84 days), nasal conjSS (14 and 84 days), conjSS (14 and 84 days) Symptoms: ODS (84 days), VAS-EDS (42 and 84 days) No difference: Schl, VR-OSDI, OSDI, VAS |
Signs: Schl | • Instillation site irritation and discomfort, mild to moderate, transient • Dysgeusia |
| |||||||
Tauber et al152 | Level 1A Phase III, multicenter, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled study | 718 | Americans ≥18 years old with the following: • Self-reported history of dry eye • AT use within 30 days • BCVA ≥0.7 logMAR in both eyes • CSS ≥2 in ≥1 eye region, CRS ≥1 in ≥1 eye • VAS-EDS ≥40 • Schl ≥1 and ≤10 in designated eye • ICSS ≥0.5 in designated eye |
LIF 5% vs vehicle twice daily for 84 days | LIF better: Signs: None Symptoms: VAS-EDS (14, 42, and 84 days), ODS (84 days), VAS-eye discomfort score (84 days) No difference: ICSS, TCSS, nasal conjSS |
Signs: ICSS, nasal conjSS, TCSS | • Instillation site irritation • Eye irritation • Blepharitis • Reduced visual acuity and blurred vision |
| |||||||
Holland et al153 | Level 1A Phase III, multicenter, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled study | 711 | Americans ≥18 years old with the following: • Self-reported history of dry eye • AT use within 30 days • BCVA ≥0.7 logMAR in both eyes • CSS ≥2 in ≥1 region in ≥1 eye, CRS ≥1 in ≥1 eye • VAS-EDS ≥40 in both eyes • Schl ≥1 and ≤10 in designated eye • ICSS ≥0.5 in designated eye |
LIF 5% vs vehicle at twice daily for 84 days | LIF better: Signs: ICSS (84 days, ad hoc analysis) Symptoms: VAS-EDS (14, 42, and 84 days), VAS (itching, foreign body sensation, eye discomfort only at 42 days) No difference: ODS, VAS (burning, photophobia, pain) |
• Instillation site irritation • Instillation site reaction • Dysgeusia • Mostly mild to moderate |
Notes:
Each study has been categorized from Level 1 through 4 as follows: Level 1A- a randomized, double-masked design; Level 1B- a randomized, double-masked design, with weak patient masking due to significant variations in treatment vs placebo side effect profiles; Level 2A- randomized, single-masked design; Level 2B- a randomized, single-masked design, with weak masking due to significant variations in treatment vs placebo side effect profiles; Level 3- randomized, non-masked; Level 4- nonrandomized, non-masked. Primary end points are shown in bold, while secondary end points are shown in italics.
Signs and symptoms are listed where the LIF group had improved parameters compared to baseline but not compared to control.
Abbreviations: AT, artificial tears; BCVA, best-corrected visual acuity; CAE, controlled adverse environment; conjSS, conjunctival staining score; CRS, conjunctival redness score; CSS, corneal staining score; ICSS, inferior corneal staining score; LIF, lifitegrast; logMAR, log of minimum angle of resolution; ODS, ocular discomfort score; OSDI, Ocular Surface Disease Index; SCSS, superior corneal staining score; Schl, Schirmer’s without anesthesia; TBUT, tear breakup time; TCSS, total corneal staining score; VAS, visual analog scale; VAS-EDS, visual analog scale eye dryness score; VR-OSDI, vision-related subscale score of OSDI.