Skip to main content
. 2001 Oct 13;323(7317):829–832. doi: 10.1136/bmj.323.7317.829

Table 1.

Scoring of reviews: quality of 52 reviews as assessed by 10 assessors

Assessor No of A scores (no problems) No of C scores (major problems)
Andrew Herxheimer 6 1
Jeanette Ezzo 4 0
Ole Olsen 3 1
Heather McIntosh 2 1
Jos Kleijnen 2 2
Peter Gøtzsche 2 4
Phil Alderson 2 2
Victoria Hadhazy 2 3
Matthias Egger 1 2
Philippa Middleton 0 3
Median (range) 2 (0-6) 2 (0-4)

Maximum number of scores given by one assessor=10.