Table 1.
Author | Year | Country | Study Object | SG (n/hip) | Age | Sex,M/F | CG (n/hip) | Age | Sex,M/F |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Animal studies | |||||||||
Kim HK(1) | 2005 | USA | piglet | 8 | 4–5 w | male | 8 | 4–5 w | male |
Aya-ay J | 2007 | Germany | piglet | 5 | 6–9 w | male | 4 | 6–9 w | male |
Vandermeer JS | 2011 | USA | piglet | 5 | 6–8 w | male | 5 | 6–8 w | male |
Kim HK (2) | 2014 | USA | piglet | 6 | 6–8 w | male | 6 | 6–8 w | male |
Cheng TL | 2014 | Australia | piglet | 4 | 6–8 w | male | 4 | 6–8 w | male |
Zou Y | 2015 | USA | piglet | 6 | 2–3 w | male | 9 | 2–3 w | male |
Aruwajoye OO | 2016 | USA | Piglet | 10 | 5–8 w | male | 10 | 5–8 w | Male |
Little DG(1) | 2003 | Australia | Rat | 16 | 14 w | female | 8 | 14 w | Female |
Little DG(2) | 2005 | Australia | Rat | 32 | 4 w | female | 16 | 4 w | Female |
Fan M | 2012 | China | Rat | 8 | NR | male | 8 | NR | Male |
Xu XL | 2015 | China | Rat | 10 | 8 w | male | 10 | 8 w | male |
Hofstaetter JG | 2009 | USA | Rabbit | 15 | 10–12 m | male | 15 | 10–12 m | Male |
Xu XL | 2015 | China | Rat | 10 | 8 w | male | 10 | 8 w | male |
Xie XW | 2013 | China | Rat | 30 | 8 w | unlimited | 30 | 8 w | unlimited |
Tan G | 2013 | China | Rat | 60 | 8 w | unlimited | 60 | 8 w | unlimited |
Xin DS(1) | 2014 | China | Rat | 15 | NR | male | 15 | NR | male |
Xin DS(2) | 2014 | China | Rat | 15 | NR | male | 15 | NR | male |
Clinical studies | |||||||||
Wang CJ | 2008 | Taiwan | Human | 23/30 | 35.7 ± 4.7y | 13/10 | 25/30 | 38.6 ± 12.6y | 20/5 |
Chen CH | 2012 | Taiwan | Human | 26/32 | 48.4 ± 11.4y | 22/4 | 26/33 | 44.2 ± 9.2y | 19/7 |
Nishii T | 2006 | Japan | Human | 14/20 | 48y | 07/7 | Aug-13 | 36y | 07/1 |
Lai KA | 2005 | Taiwan | Human | 20/29 | 42.6y | NR | 20/25 | 42.4y | NR |
Lee YK | 2015 | Korea | Human | 55/55 | 43.8 ± 11.8y | 39/1 | 55/55 | 45.2 ± 11.6y | 41/1 |
Kang P | 2012 | China | Human | 39/55 | 43.8y | 6 | 40/52 | 45.3y | 4 |
Gao yan | 2016 | China | Human | 32/32 | 23–55y | 37/18 | 32/32 | 23–55y | 35/17 |
21/11 | 22/10 |
SG: study group or bisphosphonates group; CG: control group. unlimited means animal gender is not limited. n/hip: animal number/hip number. w- weeks. y: years old. m: month. NR: not report.