Skip to main content
. 2018 Jan 23;8:1450. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-19884-z

Table 1.

Summary of the basic information.

Author Year Country Study Object SG (n/hip) Age Sex,M/F CG (n/hip) Age Sex,M/F
Animal studies
Kim HK(1) 2005 USA piglet 8 4–5 w male 8 4–5 w male
Aya-ay J 2007 Germany piglet 5 6–9 w male 4 6–9 w male
Vandermeer JS 2011 USA piglet 5 6–8 w male 5 6–8 w male
Kim HK (2) 2014 USA piglet 6 6–8 w male 6 6–8 w male
Cheng TL 2014 Australia piglet 4 6–8 w male 4 6–8 w male
Zou Y 2015 USA piglet 6 2–3 w male 9 2–3 w male
Aruwajoye OO 2016 USA Piglet 10 5–8 w male 10 5–8 w Male
Little DG(1) 2003 Australia Rat 16 14 w female 8 14 w Female
Little DG(2) 2005 Australia Rat 32 4 w female 16 4 w Female
Fan M 2012 China Rat 8 NR male 8 NR Male
Xu XL 2015 China Rat 10 8 w male 10 8 w male
Hofstaetter JG 2009 USA Rabbit 15 10–12 m male 15 10–12 m Male
Xu XL 2015 China Rat 10 8 w male 10 8 w male
Xie XW 2013 China Rat 30 8 w unlimited 30 8 w unlimited
Tan G 2013 China Rat 60 8 w unlimited 60 8 w unlimited
Xin DS(1) 2014 China Rat 15 NR male 15 NR male
Xin DS(2) 2014 China Rat 15 NR male 15 NR male
Clinical studies
Wang CJ 2008 Taiwan Human 23/30 35.7 ± 4.7y 13/10 25/30 38.6 ± 12.6y 20/5
Chen CH 2012 Taiwan Human 26/32 48.4 ± 11.4y 22/4 26/33 44.2 ± 9.2y 19/7
Nishii T 2006 Japan Human 14/20 48y 07/7 Aug-13 36y 07/1
Lai KA 2005 Taiwan Human 20/29 42.6y NR 20/25 42.4y NR
Lee YK 2015 Korea Human 55/55 43.8 ± 11.8y 39/1 55/55 45.2 ± 11.6y 41/1
Kang P 2012 China Human 39/55 43.8y 6 40/52 45.3y 4
Gao yan 2016 China Human 32/32 23–55y 37/18 32/32 23–55y 35/17
21/11 22/10

SG: study group or bisphosphonates group; CG: control group. unlimited means animal gender is not limited. n/hip: animal number/hip number. w- weeks. y: years old. m: month. NR: not report.