Table 3. Alternate Day Modified Fasting.
Study | Participants | Duration (Weeks) |
BMI (kg/m2) |
Intervention | Methods | Δ Fat mass (kg) |
Δ Fat Mass (%) |
Δ Lean Mass | Δ Body Weight (kg) |
Δ Body Weight (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||||||||
Bhutani et al. (2013)(131) | 64 obese males and females Aged 42±2 (ADMF), 45±5 (combo) | 12 | 35±1 | Alternate day modified fast (ADMF) | ADMF: alternated between fasting days (25% baseline calories) and ad libitum on feast days. | ADMF: ↓ 2.0±1.0kg** | ADMF: ↓ 4.7%** | ADMF: ↓ 1.0±1.0kg | ADMF: ↓ 3.0±1.0kg*** | ADMF: ↓ 3.2%*** |
| ||||||||||
Catenacci et al. (2016)§(54) | 26 healthy obese subjects (Aged 39.6±9.5) | 8 | ADF: 35.8±4 | Alternate day fast (ADF) | ADF: alternated ad libitum feeding and fasting days without food intake | ↓ 3.7±0.5kg*** | ↓ 1.1±0.3%** | ↓ 3.2±0.6kg*** | ↓ 8.2±0.9kg*** | ↓ 8.8±0.9%*** |
| ||||||||||
Eshghinia&Mohammadzadeh (2013)(132) | 15 overweight and obese females (Aged 33±6) | 6 | 33.16±5.02 | Modified fast consuming 25–30% energy needs. | Consumed 25–30% energy needs diet on 3 weekly fasting days (Sat, Mon and Thursday) and consumed a diet of 1700–1800 kcal/d on feast days. | N/A | ↓ 2.8%*** | ↓ 6.0kg*** | ↓ 7.1%*** | |
| ||||||||||
Hoddy et al. (2016)(133) | 54 (47 females, 7 male) | 8 | 34±1 | ADMF consuming 25% energy needs. | Alternating 25% baseline energy needs on fast day, ad libitum on feast days. | Tertile 1: ↓ 2kg*** | Tertile1: ↓ 6±1%*** | Tertile 1: ↓ 1kg*** | Tertile 1: ↓ 3.7kg*** | Tertile 1: ↓ 4±1%*** |
Tertile 2: ↓ 2kg*** | Tertile 2: ↓ 6±1%*** | Tertile 2: ↓ 2kg*** | Tertile 2: ↓ 3.8kg*** | Tertile 2: ↓ 4±1%*** | ||||||
(Aged 47±3, 46±2, 47±2) | Tertiles based on degree of insulin resistance. | Tertile 3: ↓ 2kg*** | Tertile 3: ↓ 5±1%*** | Tertile 3: ↓ 1kg*** | Tertile 3: ↓ 3.8kg*** | Tertile 3: ↓ 4±1%*** | ||||
| ||||||||||
Hoddy et al. (2014)(119) | 74 obese | 8 | L: 35± 1 | ADMF consuming 500 calories. | ADMF consuming 500 calories at either lunch or dinner and ad libitum on feast days. | L: ↓ 1.8kg*** | L: ↓ 4.3%*** | L: ↓ 1.3kg*** | L: ↓ 3.5±0.4kg*** | L: ↓ 3.8±0.5%*** |
(Aged 45±3 lunch (L), 46±2 dinner (D) | D: 34 ± 1 | D: ↓ 2.6kg*** | D: ↓ 6.2%*** | D: ↓ 1.4kg*** | D: ↓ 4.1±0.5kg*** | D: ↓ 4.2±0.5%*** | ||||
| ||||||||||
Klempel et al. (2013)(134) | 35 obese (Aged 25–65) | 8 | 30–39.9 | ADMF consuming 25% energy needs. | ADMF: High Fat (HF) or Low Fat (LF). Alternating between 25% and 125% energy needs. | HF: ↓ 5.4±1.5kg*** | HF: ↓ 11.1%*** | HF: ↑ 1.1±1.3kg | HF: ↓ 4.3±1.0kg*** | HF: ↓ 4.8±1.1%*** |
LF: ↓ 4.2±0.6kg*** | LF: ↓ 8.8%*** | LF: ↑ 0.5±0.7kg | LF: ↓ 3.7±0.7kg*** | LF: ↓ 4.2±0.8%*** | ||||||
| ||||||||||
Trepanowski et al. (2017) (135) | 100 overweight and obese subjects | 26 | 35 ± 4 | ADMF consuming 25% daily energy needs. | ADMF: 6 months weight loss alternating 25% and 125% of caloric needs. | ↓ 4.2kg* | ↓ 11.1%* | ↓ 1.5kg | ↓ 6.5kg* | ↓ 6.8%* |
86 females, 14 males (Aged 44±11) | 52 | Additional 6 months maintenance alternating 50% and 150% of caloric needs. | ↓ 2.0kg | ↓ 5.3% | ↓ 0.9kg | ↓ 5.7kg* | ↓ 6.0%* | |||
| ||||||||||
Varady et al. (2013)(12) | 32 (Aged 35–65) | 12 | 20–29.9 | ADMF consuming 25% daily energy needs. | ADMF: 25% daily caloric intake and ad libitum on feast days. | ↓ 3.6±0.7kg*** | ↓ 13.8%*** | ↓ 1.6 kg | ↓ 5.2±0.9kg*** | ↓ 6.5±1.0%*** |
| ||||||||||
Varady et al. (2009)(123) Klempel et al. (2010)(145) | 16 obese males and females (Aged 46±2) | 8 | 34 ± 1 | ADMF consuming 25% daily energy needs. | ADMF: 25% daily energy needs and ad libitum on feast days. | ↓ 5.4±0.8kg* | ↓ 3.0%* | ↓ 0.1±0.1 kg | ↓ 5.6±1.0kg*** | ↓ 5.8±1.1%*** |
| ||||||||||
Varady et al. (2015) (146) | 29 overweight women (Aged: LF: 43.2±2.3 HF: 42.4±3.0) | 8 | LF: 34.4±8 | ADMF consuming 25% energy needs. | Alternating 25% daily energy needs (1 meal) in either a LF (25% fat) or HF (45% fat) diet and ad libitum on feast days. | LF: ↓ 1.5 kg* | LF: ↓ 4.1%* | N/A | LF: ↓ 4.3 kg* | LF: ↓ 4.9%* |
HF: 34.6±7 | HF: ↓ 2.9kg* | HF: ↓ 8.0%* | HF: ↓ 4.7 kg* | HF: ↓ 5.3%* |
Note.
Alternate day fasting which included no food intake;
ADMF: alternate day modified fasting; ADF: alternate day fasting; CR: calorie restriction; L: lunch; D: dinner; HF: high fat; LF: low fat
p≤.05
p≤.01
p≤.001