Table 2.
Case presentation comparisons
Categories | Case 1: “Allan” | Case 2: Dean Potter | Case 3: Dan Osman |
---|---|---|---|
Baseline social functioning | Excellent | Fair to limited | Variable/poor |
Risk for extreme sports | Medium | Very high | Very high |
Level of skill attained at chosen extreme sport | “Weekend warrior” | Elite professional | Elite professional |
Relationships, family stability | Fairly good | Relatively unstable | Moderately unstable |
Genetic predisposition for risk taking | Unknown | High | High |
Treatment history | No known treatment | No known treatment | No known treatment |
Presumptive psychiatric diagnosis | Dysthymia (persistent depression); rule out ADHD; rule out SUDs, partner/relational problems, and generalized anxiety disorder | Impulse control disorder, ADHD, generalized anxiety disorder, conduct disorder, parent-child problems, narcissism; rule out bipolar disorder 1 (manic with psychotic features); rule out SUDs | ADHD, severe conduct disorder, cluster B personality traits; rule out SUDs |
Expressed suicidality | Unknown | Extremely cavalier | Very cavalier |
Conscious awareness of likelihood of death | Risk taker aware of life-endangering nature of sport, embraced the thrill-seeking component of his sport | Fatalistic, intimately aware, and embracing closeness to death as part of the excitement and challenge of his sport | Enjoyed the ability to “cheat” death and felt “bulletproof” |
ADHD = attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; SUDs= substance use disorders.