Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 2;27(1):18–25. doi: 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2017-053759

Table 1.

Status quo and e-cigarette substitution, premature deaths and life years lost for all cohorts, men and women combined

Outcome Year 2016 2026 2060 2080 2100 Cumulative (2016–2100) Deaths prevented/life years gained* % Change relative to status quo
Status Quo Scenario†
 Premature deaths 4 61 588 4 70 743 3 16 556 1 67 037 2905 26 065 448
 Life years lost 5 689 458 5 625 286 2 626 503 6 85 593 1852 248 639 532
Optimistic Scenario‡
 Premature deaths 4 61 588 3 80 832 2 33 243 56 399 459 19 484 289 6 581 159 25.2%
 Life years lost 5 689 458 3 839 765 1 345 385 1 83 297 294 161 905 579 86 733 953 34.9%
Pessimistic Scenario§
 Premature deaths 4 61 588 4 56 297 2 98 689 1 27 706 2188 24 432 065 1 633 383 6.3%
 Life years lost 5 689 458 5 261 398 2 319 388 5 28 926 1396 227 835 203 20 804 329 8.4%

*Life years gained=life years lost in Status Quo Scenario − Life years lost in E-cigarette Substitution Scenario.

†Status Quo Scenario: smoking rates evolve from initial 2016 levels based on age, gender and cohort-specific smoking initiation and cessation rates in the absence of e-cigarette use.

‡Optimistic Scenario: e-cigarettes excess risk 5% of smoking, 5% of the population continues to initiate cigarette smoking or remain as smokers, the remainder of never smokers then initiate e-cigarette use at the rate of cigarette smoking initiation in the Status Quo Scenario, and both smokers and e-cigarette users quit at the rate of smokers in the Status Quo Scenario.

§Pessimistic Scenario: e-cigarettes excess risk 40% of smoking, 10% of the population continues to initiate cigarette smoking or remain as smokers, the remainder of never smokers then initiate e-cigarette use at the 150% rate of cigarette smoking initiation in the Status Quo Scenario, and e-cigarette users quit at 50% of the rate of smokers in the Status Quo Scenario and smokers quit at the Status Quo cessation rate.