Table 1.
Tissue Type | Tissue or Material | Typical Applications | E (kPa) | t1/2 (s) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Interstitial and connective | Fat | - | 0.02147 | 10047 |
Tendon | - | 310,000147 | 1149 | |
Skin | - | 4.5–8148 | - | |
Vascular | Carotid artery | - | 90147 | - |
Nervous | Spinal cord | - | 27–89147 | - |
Brain | - | 0.2–1.0147,150 | 10047 | |
Viscera | Lung | - | 5147 | - |
Kidney | - | 2.5147 | - | |
Liver | - | 0.64147 | 10047 | |
Lymph node | - | 0.12147 | - | |
Mammary gland | - | 0.16147 | - | |
Musculoskeletal | Cardiac muscle | - | 20–150147 | - |
Skeletal muscle | - | 10–100147,150 | - | |
Pre-calcified bone | - | 30150 | - | |
Bone marrow | - | 0.3–24.7151 | 1047 | |
Cartilage | - | 20150 | - | |
Articular cartilage | - | 950147 | - | |
Bone - Cancellous | - | 350,000152 | - | |
Bone – Compact | - | 11,500,000152 | - | |
Tooth dentin | - | >10,000,000153 | - | |
Tooth enamel | - | ~100,000,000153 | - | |
Embryonic | Gastrulation | - | 0.01154 | - |
Natural ECM | Collagen hydrogels | - | 0.01–6155,158 | 1155 |
Fibrin hydrogels | - | 0.01–0.5155 | 1155 | |
rBM (Matrigel) | - | 0.01–0.5155 | 50155 | |
Gelatin – covalently crosslinked | - | 0.6–13156 | n/a | |
Hyaluronic acid hydrogels | - | 4–9545 | n/a | |
Synthetic matrix | Alginate hydrogels | 2D and 3D matrices, programmable viscoelastic properties, coupled with cell adhesive ligands or interpenetrating network with natural ECM, option for degradability | 0.1–11044,47 | 44–330047 |
Polyacrylamide | 2D elastic substrates coated with ECM | 0.1–4054 | n/a | |
Agarose hydrogels | 2D elastic substrates coated with ECM | 5–10044,155 | >1000155 | |
Poly(ethylene glycol) hydrogels | Covalently-crosslinked 2D and 3D matrices, coupled with cell adhesive ligands, incorporation of degradable elements | 0.1–16044,110 | n/a | |
Polystyrene | Traditional tissue culture material (plasma-treated for promoting cell adhesion) | 3,000,000125 | n/a | |
PDMS | 2D elastomer for applying extrinsic strain | 5–100115 | n/a | |
PDMS micropillars | 2D studies to measure and/or manipulate cell intrinsic forces | 2.8–60157* | n/a |
Values = XReference, E = Elastic modulus (assume E = 2G′ (1+ ν), G′ storage modulus, ν = 0.5), t1/2 = time to reach half of initial normalized stress during constant applied strain (Box 1), rBM = recombinant basement membrane, PDMS = polydimethylsiloxane; - indicates value not reported
Effective elastic modulus, Eeff