Table 2.
Line | P4 | P6 | P8 | P10 | P12 | P15 | P21 | P30 | P60 | P90 | P120 | P180 | P240 | P365 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P23H-1 | = | = | = | PNx | PN, ONL* | PN, ONL76, IS, OS, MG, MGo | PN, ONL, IS, OS, MGi, MGo | PN, ONL51, IS, OS, MGi | PNx, ONL27, ISx, OSx, MG | PNx, ONL†, ISx, OS†, RPEa | ONL†, ISx, OS†, MCh | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, MCs, INL, IPL, MN, RPEa, RPEn | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, MCs, INL, IPL, MN, RPEa, RPEn |
P23H-3 | – | = | = | = | PNx, ONL* | PNx, ONL, OS | PN, ONL, IS, OS MGo | PN, ONL77, IS, OS MGo | PN, ONL, IS, OS, MCh. MG, MGi, MGo | PN, ONL60, IS, OS, MCh, MGi, MGo | ONL40, IS, OS, MCh, MGi, MGo | ONL, ISx, OSx, MCh | ONL28x, ONL†, ISx, OS†, MCh | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, MCs, RPEn, RPEa, IPL |
P23H-2 | – | – | – | – | = | = | PNx | PNx, MGi**, MGo** | PNx, ONL*, MGi**, | PNx, ONL | PNx, ONL, IS, OS | PNx, ONL73, IS, OS, MCh | ONL, PNx, IS, OS, MCh | PNx, ONL61, ISx, OSx, MCh |
S334ter-7 | PNx, fewMG | PN, dPR, IS, MG, MGi | PN, ONL80*, dPR, ISx, OS†, MG, MGi | PN, ONL61, dPR, ISx, OS†, MG, MGi | PN, ONL24x ONL†, dPR, ISx, OS†, MG, MGi | PN, dPR, ISx, OS†, ONL†, fewMG | PNx, ONL†, dPR, IS†, OS†, fewMG | PNx, ONL†, IS†, OS† MG** | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | – | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa |
S334ter-3 | PNx | PNx | PN, dPR, OS† | PN, ONL*, dPR, IS, OS†, MG MGo | PN, ONL55*, dPR, ISx, OS†, MG, MGo | PN, ONL34, dPR, ISx, OS†, MG | PNx, ONL†, ISx, OS†, MG** | PNx, ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh | PNx, ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, IPL, MN | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, IPL, MN, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, IPL, MN, RPEa, RPEn | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, IPL, MN, RPEa, RPEn | – | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, IPL, MN, RPEa, RPEn |
S334ter-5 | = | = | dPR, OS | PNx, dPR, OS, fewMG | PN, ONL*, dPR, IS, OS, OSd, MG, MGo | PN, ONL75, dPR, IS, OS, OSd, MG, MGo | PN, ONL50, dPR, ISx, OS, OSd, fewMG | PNx, ONL40, dPR, ISx, OSx, fewMG, MGi** | ONL†, ISx, OS† | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, MN, MG** | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn, IPL | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn, IPL | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn, IPL |
S334ter-4 | – | = | = | = | PNx | PNx, OSv | PN, ONL*, OSv, fewMG, fewMGo | PNx, ONL76, OS, OSv, fewMG | PNx, ONL50, IS, OSx, MG**, fewMGo | PNx | PNx, ONL34x, ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, MG** | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn, IPL | ONL†, IS†, OS†, MCh, RPEa, RPEn, IPL |
S334ter-9 | – | – | – | – | = | = MG** | = | = | = | = | ONL* | ONL, PNx, MG** | ONL, PNx, IS, OS | ONL75, PNx, ISx, OSx, MG** |
=, no difference from normal SD retina; –, not examined.
For each transgenic line, the observations are based on examination of the eyes from 2–5 rats at each age, and compared to those of 3 SD control rats at each age.
Note: Where superior/inferior asymmetry exists, the earliest changes are typically seen in the superior posterior retina, which are indicated here as the first degenerative changes; these are not seen in the peripheral or inferior retina until slightly later ages.
PN, pyknotic nuclei number in ONL greater than normal (2+ per 180-μm field). PNx, more PN than normal, but < 2 per 180-μm field.
ONL*, overall outer nuclear layer first thinner than normal (P < 0.5). ONL, ONL thinner than normal. ONLxx, % of control of ONL as close to 75%, 50% and 25% of control as was measured. ONL†, ONL reduced to less than one complete row in most degenerated region. (Note: the quantitative measure of % of control ONL thickness is an overall measurement {see Methods}, whereas the ONL† is descriptive of the most degenerated region. Thus, P23H-3 at P240, for example, has an ONL that is 28% of control overall, but is less than one complete row in the superior posterior retina.)
IS, inner segments shorter than normal. ISx, IS reduced to very short, thin nubs. IS†, IS missing.
OS, outer segments shorter than normal. OSx, OS reduced to very short nubs. OS†, OS missing. OSd, OS more disorganized than normal. OSv, many OS vacuolated or pale-staining.
dPR, displaced photoreceptors in outer segment zone greater number than normal.
INL, inner nuclear layer thinner than normal.
MCh, Müller cell hypertrophy in the IPL.
MCs, Müller cell seal in outer retina.
MN, apparent microneuromas in INL.
RPEn, RPE neovascularization from retinal capillaries.
RPEa, RPE attenuation at focal points.
IPL, strands of INL nuclei cross the IPL.