Duthie (1981)59
|
|
|
|
Taylor (1983)87
|
|
|
|
Rogers (1988)88
|
|
|
|
Sparks (1995)58
|
|
Double blind study with randomization to PMO (30 mL placed in the barium and 10 mL in the enema tube; n=70) or barium alone (n=71)
Incomplete studies (n=3) and those receiving hyoscine (n=14) subsequently excluded
Assessed colonic spasm (present vs. absent) and exam quality (excellent, good, poor)
Patient symptom questionnaire
|
39/60 (65%) controls vs. 23/64 (36%) PMO with spasm (P<0.001)
No marked difference in study quality
No marked difference in patient symptoms/ acceptability
|
Asao (2003)57
|
|
Assigned to: 1) No treatment (n=97); 2) hyoscine IM (n=105); 3) PMO (30 mL of 8 mL PMO in 100 mL water) via enema tube n=90; 4) PO (30 mL of 8 mL PMO in 100 mL water) in barium
Radiologist blinded to treatment assessed spasm in ascending, transverse, descending colon graded none, mild, severe
Blinded radiologist assessed for spasm
|
|