Table 1, continued | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Authors sample size | |||||
NP status | Methodological quality of studies | Intervention Co intervention | Comparison group co intervention | Outcomes measures of interest | Clinical relevance status on timing outcomes: between groups value and effect sizes |
Bronfort et al. and Leininger et al. | |||||
272 | |||||
ASNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG: MT3 Cx-Tx-STT | ||||
Number of sessions decided by therapist over 12 weeks | CG1: UMC | ||||
(anti-inflam, acetaminophen/ narcotic; Muscle relaxants) | |||||
CG2: Home Exercise advice | |||||
6 to 8 sessions per day | Pain (NPRS) | ||||
Functional disabilities (NDI) | |||||
Satisfaction with care (information, general care) | |||||
(CROM) | |||||
Quality of life (SF-36) | IG vs CG1: Yes: At 12 and 52 weeks ( 0.005; SMD 0.6–0.5) | ||||
Yes: At 8 and 26 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 0.5–0.4) | |||||
Yes: At 12 and 52 weeks ( 0.005; MD 11.6–16.4) | |||||
No | |||||
No | |||||
IG vs CG2: No difference on all outcome measures | |||||
Masaracchio et al. | |||||
64 | |||||
ASNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG: MT3 (MT1 Tx MT2 Cx) Exercise | ||||
2 times/1 week for all groups | CG : MT2 Cx Exercises | Pain (NPRS) | |||
Functional disabilities (NDI) | Yes: At 1 week ( 0,001; SMD 1.0) Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.1) | ||||
Ganesh et al. | |||||
80 | |||||
ASNP | Level B | ||||
7/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded, ITT and dropouts ( 20%) | IG: MT2 Cx (PAIVMS) Exercise | ||||
5 times/week for 2 weeks and for all groups | CG1: MT4 Cx (SNAGs) Exercise | ||||
CG2: Exercise alone | Pain (VAS) | ||||
Disability (NDI) | |||||
(CROM) | No | ||||
No |
ANP: acute neck pain/SNP: subacute neck pain/ASNP: acute-subacute neck pain/VAS: Visual Analogue Scale/NDI: Neck Disability Index/CROM: Active Cervical Range of Motion/PPT: Pressure Pain Threshold/US: ultrasound/NPRS: Numeric Pain Rating Scale/FABQ: Fear-Avoidance-Belief-Questionnaire/SF-36: Short-form-health-survey/NPQ: Northwick Pain Questionnaire/UMC: Usual Medical Care/Cx: cervical/Th: thoracic/MOB: Mobilization/SNAGs: Sustained Natural Apophyseal Glides/HVLA: high velocity low amplitude thrust/IG: Intervention Group/CG: Control Group/IRT: Infrared Radiation Therapy/PAIVMS: Passive Accessory Intervertebral Movements/STT: Soft-Tissues-Techniques/SUS: Sham Ultrasound/Yes: significant difference with moderate to large clinical effect size/No: no significant difference with small clinical effect size on all timing outcome measures.