Table 1.
Summary of articles for patients with acute-subacute neck pain
Authors sample size | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
NP status | Methodological quality of studies | Intervention Co intervention | Comparison group co intervention | Outcomes measures of interest | Clinical relevance status on timing outcomes: between groups value and effect sizes |
Puentedura et al. | |||||
24 | |||||
ANP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG: MT1 Cx exercise | ||||
5 sessions over 2 weeks | CG: MT1 Tx exercise | ||||
5 sessions over 2 weeks | Pain (NPRS) | ||||
Functional disabilities (NDI) | |||||
(FABQ) | Yes: From 1 week to 6 months ( 0.005; SMD 2.2–2.7) | ||||
Yes: From 1 week to 6 months ( 0.05; SMD 1) | |||||
Yes: At 6 months ( 0.04; SMD 1.1) | |||||
Gonzalez-Iglesias et al. | |||||
45 | |||||
SNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG : MT1 Tx | ||||
once a week over 3 weeks | |||||
Electro/thermal therapy 5 times over 3 weeks | CG: Electro/thermal therapy 5 times over 3 weeks | Pain (VAS) | |||
Functional disabilities (NPQ) | |||||
(CROM) | |||||
-Flex | |||||
-Ext | |||||
-R Rot | |||||
-L Rot | |||||
-R Lat Flex | |||||
-L Lat Flex | Yes: From post treatment to 4 weeks ( 0.001; SMD 2) | ||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.001; SMD 2.7–2.6) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 2.5–1.6) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 1.8–1.1) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 1.9–2.0) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 2.1–1.6) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 2.2–1.9) | |||||
Yes: At post treatment and 2 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 2.5–1.4) | |||||
Gonzalez-Iglesias et al. | |||||
45 | |||||
SNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG : MT1 Tx | ||||
once a week over 3 weeks | |||||
Electro/thermal therapy 6 times over 3 weeks | CG: Electro/thermal therapy 6 times over 3 weeks | Pain (NPRS) | |||
Functional disabilities (NPQ) | |||||
(CROM) | |||||
-Flex | |||||
-Ext | |||||
-L Lat Flex | |||||
-R Lat Flex | |||||
-L Rot | |||||
-R Rot | Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 2.8) | ||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 2.7) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 2.0) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.5) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.7) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.9) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.4) | |||||
Yes: At 1 week ( 0.001; SMD 1.4) | |||||
Nagrale et al. | |||||
60 | |||||
ASNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG: MT2 (myotensive technique trigger and tender points) | ||||
3 times/week over 4 weeks for all groups | CG: MT2 (myotensive technique) | Pain (VAS) | |||
Functional disabilities (NDI) | |||||
(CROM) Lat flex | Yes: At 2 and 4 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 1.2–1.7) | ||||
Yes: At 2 and 4 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 0.8–0.9) | |||||
Yes: At 2 and 4 weeks ( 0.05; SMD 2.0–3.8) | |||||
Blikstad and Gemmell | |||||
45 | |||||
ASNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG1: MT2 (Activator trigger point therapy) | ||||
IG2:MT2 (myofascial band therapy) | |||||
1 time for all groups | CG: Sham Ultrasound (SUS) | Pain (NPRS) | |||
Functional disabilities (CROM) | No | ||||
No | |||||
Gemmell et al. | |||||
45 | |||||
ASNP | Level A | ||||
9/11 | |||||
No for patient and care provider blinded | IG1: MT2 (Ischaemic compression) | ||||
IG2:MT2 (Trigger point pressure release) | |||||
1 time for all groups | CG: Sham Ultrasound (SUS) | Pain (VAS) | |||
Functional disabilities | |||||
(CROM) | No | ||||
No |