Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Gastroenterology. 2017 Nov 2;154(3):556–567.e18. doi: 10.1053/j.gastro.2017.10.036

Appendix Table 5.

Outcomes with colonoscopy screening strategies that vary by the ages to begin and end screening among transplant Cystic Fibrosis patients.

Outcomes per 1,000 transplant cystic fibrosis individuals free of diagnosed cancer at age 30 years in 2017 (with organ transplant at age 30, 3% discounted)

Screening tests Surveillance
COLs
Total
COLs
Compli
-cations
CRC
Casesc
CRC
deatha,c
LY
with
CRC
LYGb Total costs
(*$1,000)
Net costs
(*$1,000)
Reductionsb (%) Efficient
strategy

FIT COLs CRC
incidencec
CRC
mortalityc

No screening 0 0 0 30 0 52 22 115 0 2064654 0 0 0 Dominated
COL 50–55 y
  3 y 0 125 173 314 2 48 13 143 15 2437339 372685 8 40 Dominated
  5 y 0 125 152 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420864 356209 8 39 Dominated
  10 y 0 124 151 293 1 48 14 143 14 2419742 355087 8 39 Dominated
COL 50–60 y
  3 y 0 125 173 314 2 48 13 143 15 2437341 372687 8 40 Dominated
  5 y 0 125 152 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420865 356211 8 39 Dominated
  10 y 0 124 151 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420644 355990 8 39 Dominated
COL 50–65 y
  3 y 0 125 173 314 2 48 13 143 15 2437341 372687 8 40 Dominated
  5 y 0 125 152 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420865 356211 8 39 Dominated
  10 y 0 124 151 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420644 355990 8 39 Dominated
COL 50–70 y
  3 y 0 125 173 314 2 48 13 143 15 2437341 372687 8 40 Dominated
  5 y 0 125 152 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420865 356211 8 39 Dominated
  10 y 0 124 151 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420644 355990 8 39 Dominated
COL 50–75 y
  3 y 0 125 173 314 2 48 13 143 15 2437341 372687 8 40 Dominated
  5 y 0 125 152 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420865 356211 8 39 Dominated
  10 y 0 124 151 293 1 48 14 143 14 2420644 355990 8 39 Dominated
COL 45–55 y
  3 y 0 200 416 628 3 38 9 137 29 2481276 416622 27 59 Dominated
  5 y 0 200 343 554 2 39 9 139 28 2438899 374244 25 58 Efficient
  10 y 0 199 342 553 2 39 9 139 28 2438362 373707 25 57 Efficient
COL 45–60 y
  3 y 0 200 416 628 3 38 9 137 29 2481280 416625 27 59 Dominated
  5 y 0 200 343 554 2 39 9 139 28 2438902 374247 25 58 Dominated
  10 y 0 199 342 553 2 39 9 139 28 2438362 373707 25 57 Dominated
COL 45–65 y
  3 y 0 200 416 628 3 38 9 137 29 2481280 416625 27 59 Dominated
  5 y 0 200 343 554 2 39 9 139 28 2438902 374247 25 58 Dominated
  10 y 0 199 342 553 2 39 9 139 28 2438362 373707 25 57 Dominated
COL 45–70 y
  3 y 0 200 416 628 3 38 9 137 29 2481280 416625 27 59 Dominated
  5 y 0 200 343 554 2 39 9 139 28 2438902 374247 25 58 Dominated
  10 y 0 199 342 553 2 39 9 139 28 2438362 373707 25 57 Dominated
COL 45–75 y
  3 y 0 200 416 628 3 38 9 137 29 2481280 416625 27 59 Dominated
  5 y 0 200 343 554 2 39 9 139 28 2438902 374247 25 58 Dominated
  10 y 0 199 342 553 2 39 9 139 28 2438362 373707 25 57 Dominated
COL 40–55 y
  3 y 0 328 774 1109 3 30 6 123 44 2707578 642923 42 74 Dominated
  5 y 0 324 591 923 3 34 7 129 42 2600975 536321 36 70 Efficient
  10 y 0 320 582 909 3 34 7 129 42 2597514 532860 35 70 Dominated
COL 40–60 y
  3 y 0 328 774 1109 3 30 6 123 44 2707578 642924 42 74 Dominated
  5 y 0 324 591 923 3 34 7 129 42 2600975 536321 36 70 Dominated
  10 y 0 320 582 909 3 34 7 129 42 2597584 532929 35 70 Dominated
COL 40–65 y
  3 y 0 328 774 1109 3 30 6 123 44 2707578 642924 42 74 Dominated
  5 y 0 324 591 923 3 34 7 129 42 2600975 536321 36 70 Dominated
  10 y 0 320 582 909 3 34 7 129 42 2597584 532929 35 70 Dominated
COL 40–70 y
  3 y 0 328 774 1109 3 30 6 123 44 2707578 642924 42 74 Dominated
  5 y 0 324 591 923 3 34 7 129 42 2600975 536321 36 70 Dominated
  10 y 0 320 582 909 3 34 7 129 42 2597584 532929 35 70 Dominated
COL 40–75 y
  3 y 0 328 774 1109 3 30 6 123 44 2707578 642924 42 74 Dominated
  5 y 0 324 591 923 3 34 7 129 42 2600975 536321 36 70 Dominated
  10 y 0 320 582 909 3 34 7 129 42 2597584 532929 35 70 Dominated
COL 35–55 y
  3 y 0 642 1265 1912 4 26 4 110 56 3346546 1281892 49 82 Optimal
  5 y 0 607 838 1451 3 31 5 122 52 3028100 963446 41 77 Efficient
  10 y 0 571 788 1364 3 32 6 125 49 2980739 916084 39 75 Dominated
COL 35–60 y
  3 y 0 642 1265 1912 4 26 4 110 56 3346548 1281894 49 82 Dominated
  5 y 0 607 838 1451 3 31 5 122 52 3028100 963446 41 77 Dominated
  10 y 0 571 788 1364 3 32 6 125 49 2980739 916084 39 75 Dominated
COL 35–65 y
  3 y 0 642 1265 1912 4 26 4 110 56 3346548 1281894 49 82 Dominated
  5 y 0 607 838 1451 3 31 5 122 52 3028100 963446 41 77 Dominated
  10 y 0 571 788 1364 3 32 6 125 49 2980739 916084 39 75 Dominated
COL 35–70 y
  3 y 0 642 1265 1912 4 26 4 110 56 3346548 1281894 49 82 Dominated
  5 y 0 607 838 1451 3 31 5 122 52 3028100 963446 41 77 Dominated
  10 y 0 571 788 1364 3 32 6 125 49 2980739 916084 39 75 Dominated
COL 35–75 y
  3 y 0 642 1265 1912 4 26 4 110 56 3346548 1281894 49 82 Dominated
  5 y 0 607 838 1451 3 31 5 122 52 3028100 963446 41 77 Dominated
  10 y 0 571 788 1364 3 32 6 125 49 2980739 916084 39 75 Dominated
COL 30–55 y
  3 y 0 1511 1826 3340 5 25 3 99 64 4622190 2557535 53 87 Efficient
  5 y 0 1316 1080 2400 4 29 4 117 57 3888961 1824306 43 80 Dominated
  10 y 0 1134 971 2110 4 31 5 121 54 3656737 1592083 41 77 Dominated
COL 30–60 y
  3 y 0 1511 1826 3340 5 25 3 99 64 4622193 2557539 53 87 Dominated
  5 y 0 1316 1080 2400 4 29 4 117 57 3888964 1824309 43 80 Dominated
  10 y 0 1134 971 2110 4 31 5 121 54 3656827 1592172 41 78 Dominated
COL 30–65 y
  3 y 0 1511 1826 3340 5 25 3 99 64 4622193 2557539 53 87 Dominated
  5 y 0 1316 1080 2400 4 29 4 117 57 3888964 1824309 43 80 Dominated
  10 y 0 1134 971 2110 4 31 5 121 54 3656827 1592172 41 78 Dominated
COL 30–70 y
  3 y 0 1511 1826 3340 5 25 3 99 64 4622193 2557539 53 87 Dominated
  5 y 0 1316 1080 2400 4 29 4 117 57 3888964 1824309 43 80 Dominated
  10 y 0 1134 971 2110 4 31 5 121 54 3656827 1592172 41 78 Dominated
COL 30–75 y
  3 y 0 1511 1826 3340 5 25 3 99 64 4622193 2557539 53 87 Dominated
  5 y 0 1316 1080 2400 4 29 4 117 57 3888964 1824309 43 80 Dominated
  10 y 0 1134 971 2110 4 31 5 121 54 3656827 1592172 41 78 Dominated

COL indicates colonoscopy; CRC, colorectal cancer; LY, Life-years; LYG, LY gained compared with no screening; Grey row indicates optimal screening strategy.

a

Including deaths from complications of screening;

b

compared with no screening;

c

CRC cases and CRC death were not discounted.