Table 3.
Study/citation | Components of intervention | Duration and frequency of intervention | Comparator | Outcomes measured | Measurement method |
Complex decongestive treatment (CDT/CDPT/DLT) | |||||
Dayes et al. 201335,a | Intensive phase: MLD and short stretch compression bandaging (Vodder or Foldi method); advice re skin care, exercise, and maintenance of healthy body weight.Followed by maintenance phase: elastic compression garments; exercise, skin care, maintenance of healthy body weight. | 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions).Subsequent maintenance treatment with daily self-care | Compression therapy: daily self treatment, as per maintenance phase, see below | 1. EAV2. HRQOL3. Limb function | 1. Manual circumference measurement2. Short Form Health Survey (SF-36)3. Disabilities of the Arm Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire |
Gradalski et al. 201582,b | Multi-layer compression bandaging and Vodder II method MLD, exercise and deep diaphragmatic breathing.Followed by maintenance phase: exercise, compression garment, arm and skin care. | 5× per week for 2 weeks (10 sessions). Followed by 6 months daily self-care. | Compression bandaging 5× per week for 2 weeks (10 sessions), followed by 6 months maintenance phase of daily self-care, see below. | 1. EAV2. HRQOL3. Patient-perceived treatment benefit | 1. Manual circumference measurement2. non-validated lymphedema questionnaire3. VAS: desire to continue treatment |
Haghighat et al. 201375,a,c | CDT phase I: Vodder method MLD; multi-layer short-stretch bandages; remedial exercise (not specified); skin care. | 5× per week for 2–3 weeks (10–15 sessions). | None | 1. EAV2. Symptom of arm heaviness | 1. Water displacement2. VAS |
Hwang et al. 201379,b,d | CDT phase I: 1 hour MLD, multi-layer low stretch compression bandaging, remedial exercises, skin care.CDT phase II: compression garments daytime, self-bandage night-time; self-MLD/self-massage; exercise; skin care. | 5× per week for 2 weeks (10 sessions).Then daily self-treatment plus 3 times per week night-time self-bandaging. | None | 1. EAV | 1. Perometry |
Kim et al. 201080,b | Termed ‘Complex Decongestive Physiotherapy (CDPT)’Intensive phase: MLD, compression therapy, exercise, breathing exercises.Maintenance phase: self-CDPT | 5× per week for 2 weeks (10 sessions). Then 6 weeks self-administered CDPT. | Complex Decongestive Therapy plus Active Resistive Exercise (CDPT+ARE), see below | 1. HRQOL | 1. SF-36 |
Complex decongestive physiotherapy (CDPT) and active resistive exercise (ARE) | |||||
Kim et al. 201080,b | Intensive phase: MLD, compression bandage, exercises and breathing exercises, plus Active Resistive Exercise (ARE) program using 0.5 kg dumbbell.Maintenance phase: self-CDPT+ARE using 1 kg dumbbell (if tolerated), wearing hosiery. | 5× per week for 2 weeks (10 sessions).Then 6 weeks self-administered CDPT+ARE. | CDPT, see above | 1. HRQOL | 1. SF-36 |
Compression bandaging (CB) and manual lymph drainage (MLD) | |||||
McNeely et al. 200436,a | Short stretch bandages plus 45 minutes daily Vodder method MLD. Education re arm care and skin care. | 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions) | CB 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions), see below | 1. EAV | 1. Water displacement & manual circumference measurement |
Compression bandaging (CB) | |||||
McNeely et al. 200436,a | Short stretch bandages. Education re arm care and skin care. | 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions) | CB+MLD 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions), see above | 1. EAV | 1. Water displacement & manual circumference measurement |
Compression therapy | |||||
Dayes et al. 201335,a | Elastic compression garments, advice re skin care, exercise and maintenance of healthy body weight. | Daily self-care with compression garments worn 12 hours per day | CDT, 5× per week for 4 weeks (20 sessions). Subsequent maintenance treatment with daily self-care, see above | 1. EAV2. HRQOL3. Limb function | 1. Manual circumference measurement2. SF-363. DASH questionnaire |
Low level laser therapy (LLLT) | |||||
Kaviani et al. 200681,b | Laser diode (product specified), output power 10 Watts at 890 nm wavelength. Treatment to five points in axilla at 1 cm distance from skin, energy density 1.5J/cm2 | 3x per week for 3 weeks, then 8 week break, then 3x per week for 3 more weeks. (18 sessions). | Sham irradiation as per LLLT, total 18 sessions. Double-blinded conditions for sham laser not specified. | 1. Symptom of arm heaviness2. Limb function3. Patient-perceived treatment benefit | 1. VAS2. Goniometry: range of movement3. VAS: desire to continue treatment |
EAV, excess arm volume; HRQOL, health-related quality of life; MLD, manual lymph drainage; VAS, visual analogue scale.
aSubgroup with BCRL duration <12 months.
bMean duration ≤9 months.
cProspective before and after (uncontrolled) study.
dRetrospective case review (uncontrolled) study.