Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Health Care Manag Sci. 2017 Aug 31:10.1007/s10729-017-9416-4. doi: 10.1007/s10729-017-9416-4

Appendix Table 3.

QALY values and costs2 for India example

Description Value Reference
Test costs ($)
 Sputum smear test 4.93 [7]
 GeneXpert test 26.57 [7]
Monthly first-line treatment costs ($)
 Patient costs 6.33 [40]
 Drug costs 3.60 [2,43,38]
 Clinic costs 31.71 [41]
Discount factor
 Annual discount rate 3% [46]
Societal losses due to an additional month of transmissibility
 Drug-sensitive TB transmission Age Costs ($) QALYS Calculated from simulation
10 2,469 −9 [14]
20 11,346 −28
30 11,460 −32
40 10,499 −41
50 11,539 −32
60 7,381 −30
70 10,424 −28
80 11,024 −16
90 11,024 −16
 Drug-resistant TB transmission Age Costs ($) QALYS Calculated from simulation
10 9,400 −9 [14]
20 14,957 −28
30 31,027 −31
40 31,867 −31
50 23,021 −30
60 23,604 −21
70 18,774 −17
80 20,036 −25
90 20,036 −24
Quality-of-life multipliers
 Healthy, treatment naive 1.00 [47]
 Healthy, with past treatment 0.94 [26]
 Healthy, on first-line treatment 0.85 Assumed
 DS TB, not on treatment 0.66 [42]
 DS TB, on first-line treatment 0.84 [34]
 DR TB, not on DR TB treatment 0.66 [42]
 DR TB, on DR TB treatment 0.75 3
Willingness-to-pay
 GDP per capita in India ($) 1450 [44]
Monthly background healthcare costs when not on TB treatment
Age Males Females [39]
0 0.20 0.19
10 0.17 0.26
20 1.23 2.63
30 1.62 2.78
40 1.66 2.92
50 2.53 2.37
60 3.31 2.44
70 4.76 4.18
Lifetime discounted costs and QALYs
 At the end of first-line treatment for a 30-year-old male by health and treatment state
Costs ($) QALYs Calculated from simulation
 Healthy (cured) 421.79 16.530 [14]
 DS TB, exiting all treatment 171.71 4.353
 DR TB, exiting all treatment 115.56 4.084
 DR TB, entering DR TB treatment 1560.00 7.079
 For a 30-year-old male DR patient successfully triaged to DR TB treatment
After Month Costs ($) QALYs Calculated from simulation
0 1559.10 7.117 [14]
1 1559.30 7.111
2 1559.40 7.105
3 1559.50 7.098
4 1559.70 7.092
5 1559.80 7.086
6 1560.00 7.079
2

Costs in this table are reported in 2012 USD, following [14], as this is the simulation used to estimate lifetime costs. Final reported results are scaled to 2015 USD using data from [45] and [36].

3

Average of no treatment and first-line treatment for patients with DS TB (effective treatment but toxic).