Table 1.
Environment | Species | Yield | SE | p | Growth rate | SE | p |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fluctuating | N. capsulatum | 0.083 | .042 | .053 | 0.053 | .026 | .048 |
Fluctuating | P. chlororaphis | 0.024 | .042 | .569 | −0.018 | .026 | .49 |
Fluctuating | P. fluorescens | 0.489 | .043 | .001 | 0.017 | .027 | .525 |
Fluctuating | P. putida | 0.114 | .043 | .009 | 0.082 | .027 | .003 |
Fluctuating | S. marcescens marc. | −0.011 | .03 | .699 | 0.034 | .043 | .426 |
Fluctuating | S. marcescens db11 | 0.016 | .03 | .587 | 0.061 | .043 | .161 |
Fluctuating | E. coli | 0.052 | .03 | .085 | 0.075 | .043 | .088 |
Fluctuating | E. aerogenes | −0.018 | .03 | .559 | −0.066 | .043 | .133 |
Fluctuating | L. adecarboxylata | 0.049 | .03 | .103 | −0.043 | .043 | .32 |
20°C | N. capsulatum | 0.002 | .043 | .967 | 0.006 | .021 | .768 |
20°C | P. chlororaphis | −0.1 | .042 | .02 | 0.012 | .021 | .57 |
20°C | P. fluorescens | −0.013 | .045 | .769 | −0.01 | .022 | .669 |
20°C | P. putida | −0.001 | .043 | .973 | −0.129 | .021 | .001 |
20°C | S. marcescens marc. | −0.006 | .054 | .918 | 0.014 | .02 | .481 |
20°C | S. marcescens db11 | 0.081 | .054 | .139 | −0.007 | .02 | .732 |
20°C | E. coli | 0.067 | .055 | .225 | 0.004 | .02 | .831 |
20°C | E. aerogenes | −0.059 | .056 | .291 | 0 | .021 | .993 |
20°C | L. adecarboxylata | 0.02 | .054 | .714 | 0.007 | .02 | .727 |
30°C | N. capsulatum | 0.006 | .056 | .92 | 0.01 | .034 | .772 |
30°C | P. chlororaphis | −0.057 | .055 | .303 | −0.034 | .033 | .311 |
30°C | P. fluorescens | 0.024 | .056 | .669 | −0.073 | .034 | .036 |
30°C | P. putida | 0.065 | .055 | .241 | −0.148 | .033 | .001 |
30°C | S. marcescens marc. | 0.067 | .048 | .17 | −0.003 | .026 | .914 |
30°C | S. marcescens db11 | 0.031 | .049 | .534 | −0.004 | .026 | .884 |
30°C | E. coli | 0.007 | .049 | .895 | −0.035 | .027 | .185 |
30°C | E. aerogenes | −0.027 | .049 | .579 | −0.063 | .026 | .019 |
30°C | L. adecarboxylata | 0.015 | .048 | .755 | −0.054 | .026 | .041 |
40°C | N. capsulatum | 0.07 | .029 | .022 | 0.023 | .015 | .131 |
40°C | P. chlororaphis | −0.006 | .042 | .887 | −0.022 | .02 | .272 |
40°C | P. fluorescens | 0.021 | .072 | .775 | 0.031 | .031 | .328 |
40°C | S. marcescens marc. | 0.009 | .049 | .859 | 0.032 | .037 | .385 |
40°C | S. marcescens db11 | 0.014 | .047 | .763 | 0.021 | .035 | .559 |
40°C | E. coli | 0.08 | .048 | .096 | −0.001 | .035 | .984 |
40°C | E. aerogenes | −0.048 | .048 | .321 | 0.008 | .036 | .818 |
40°C | L. adecarboxylata | 0.027 | .055 | .622 | 0.005 | .041 | .911 |
Positive estimate for difference indicates that the fluctuation‐adapted clones have a higher yield or growth rate than constant (30°C)‐adapted clones. Values indicate estimated marginal means from mixed models testing for the fixed effect of evolution, and random effect of population, nested within evolutionary treatment. All models also included inoculum size as a continuous covariate to control for different starting densities in growth measurements (not shown). These results were compiled in the meta‐analysis.