eTable 1. Included studies and their characteristics (in alphabetical order).
Reference | Country | Study design | Study period |
Number of patients with empty sella |
Age (mean ± SD) |
Symptoms |
Initially imaging, followed by endocrinologic diagnostics |
Radiological method |
Radiological diagnostic criteria empty sella present |
Study quality*1 |
Cannavo 2002 (23) |
Italy | Case-control study*2 | Not available | 43 | 48 ± 12 | Headache, impaired vision | Yes | MRI | Yes | 8 |
Colao 2013 (24) |
Italy | Case-control study*3 | Not available | 94 | 50.1 ± 9.3 | Not available | Yes (78%)*4 | CT, MRI | Yes | 10 |
Lupi 2011 (22) |
Italy | Case-control study*5 | 2006–2009 | 85 (PES), 16 (SES) |
48 ± 1 | Headache, impaired vision, sexual dysfunction, oligomenorrhea, rhinoliquorrhea*6 |
Yes | MRI | Yes | 10 |
Zuhur 2014 (21) |
Turkey | Prospective cohort study | 2011–2012 | 81 | 49.9 ± 14.5 | Headache, fatigue, arthralgia, myalgia, nausea, weight loss, sexual dysfunction, amenorrhea*7 |
Yes | MRI | Yes | 9 |
*1 Based on the quality assessment criteria of Guyatt et al. (GRADE working group) (18, 19) (0 = low to 10 = high quality)
*2 43 patients (10 men, 33 women) with PES and 40 controls (9 men, 31 women) without goiter or prior intake of thyroid hormone
*3 94 patients (39 men, 55 women) with PES, of which 78% had an incidental finding, and 94 controls from a cohort of 1484 individuals with normal pituitary function, matched for age (± 1 year), body mass index, and sex
*4 In 78% incidental, in 22% imaging for pituitary disorder
*5 85 patients (18 men, 67 women) with PES and 214 healthy controls (48 men, 166 women) with normal findings on examination and normal pituitary function, as well as 16 patients with autoimmune hypophysitis, of these at least 14 histologically confirmed
*6 No differentiation between PES, SES, and hypophysitis
*7 A non-incidental finding has to be assumed in <10% CT, computed tomography; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; PES, primary empty sella syndrome; SD, standard deviation; SES, secondary empty sella syndrome