Means and variances of bias-corrected acceptance rates [P(Yes)] for NS (new-similar) and O (old) items. O? refers to old probes, and NS? refers to new-similar probes. These are the relations between p(O?) and p(NS?) for strong NS items, weak NS items, and O items in the control condition of Experiment 5 (Panel A) and in the repetition condition (Panel B). In Panel A, strong NS performance is completely complementary, whereas weak NS and O performance are both partially complementary and reality-consistent. In Panel B, performance for all items is partially complementary and reality-consistent.