Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 9;15(3):e1002526. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1002526

Table 2. PACE-UP and PACE-Lift studies: Accelerometry outcomes at 3 months, 12 months, and 3 years (PACE-UP) and 4 years (PACE-Lift).

Outcomes PACE-UP study PACE-UP study PACE-Lift study
Postal versus Control Nurse versus Control Intervention versus Control
  Effect 95% CI p-value Effect 95% CI p-value Effect 95% CI p-value
Step counts
3 months 692 (363–1,020) <0.001 1,173 (844–1,501) <0.001 1,041 (519–1,563) <0.001
12 months 642 (329–955) <0.001 677 (365–989) <0.001 610 (104–1,117) 0.02
3 years 627 (198–1,056) 0.004 670 (237–1,102) 0.002  
4 years     407 (−177–992) 0.17
MVPA in ≥10-minute bouts
3 months 43 (26–60) <0.001 61 (44–78) <0.001 63 (40–86) <0.001
12 months 33 (17–49) <0.001 35 (19–51) <0.001 39 (16–62) <0.001
3 years 28 (7–49) 0.009 24 (3–45) 0.03  
4 years     32 (5–60) 0.02
Daily sedentary time (minutes)
3 months −2 (−12–7) 0.59 −7 (−16–3) 0.16 −1 (−13–11) 0.84
12 months 1 (-8–10) 0.82 0 (−9–9) 0.96 0 (−15–15) 0.97
3 years −1 (−12–11) 0.90 −2 (−14–9) 0.69  
4 years     7 (−9–23) 0.37
Daily wear time (minutes)
3 months 2 (−8–12) 0.69 4 (−6–14) 0.39 14 (0, 28) 0.06
12 months 9 (−1–19) 0.08 9 (−1–19) 0.07 5 (−11–22) 0.51
3 years 8 (−5–20) 0.23 7 (−6–19) 0.32  
4 years     9 (−10–28) 0.35

Analyses using all available data at each follow-up.

PACE-UP study: N = 954 at 3 months, 956 at 12 months, and 681 at 3 years. PACE-Lift study: N = 280 at 3 months, 273 at 12 months, and 225 at 4 years.

All models include treatment group, practice, gender, age at randomisation, and month of baseline accelerometry as fixed effects and household as a random effect in a multilevel linear regression model. The results shown are the change in each intervention group relative to the change in their control group.

The effect estimates, 95% confidence intervals, and p-values were obtained from the model output.