Table 1.
Flesch-Kincaid formula | SMOGa formula | |
---|---|---|
Original development and reference | The formula has been designed for evaluating readability of technical texts for US military by Kincaid (Kincaid et al. 1975). | McLaughlin (McLaughlin 1969) |
Analysis based on | Sentence length and syllable count | Number of complex words (3 and more syllables) |
Easier formula for manual calculation (not used in this study) | G = (12*(B/W)) + (0 .4*(W/S)) – 16 G—grade level W—number of words B—number of syllables S—number of sentences |
G = FLOOR(√C) + 3 G—grade level C—number of complex words (3 and more syllables) FLOOR—round the result of (√C) down to the closest perfect square. |
Higher precision formula used by the software in this study | G = (11.8*(B/W)) + (0.39*(W/S)) − 15.59 | G = 1.0430*√C + 3.1291 |
aOriginally, McLaughlin recommended using 10 consecutive sentences from the beginning of the text, 10 sentences from the middle and 10 from the end; the formula was meant to facilitate manual calculations. In our study, the calculations were based on the whole text (and not subsamples of the text) and standardized