Table 1.
Author | Study type | Journal | Year | Period of review | Country | No. of patients | M:F | Mean age | Comparator | Strings:no strings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pryor | Prospective cohort | J Urol | 1991 | – | USA | 73 | 45:28 | – | Pain score at removal, urinary symptoms | 44:29 |
(23–72) | ||||||||||
Bockholt | Retrospective cohort | BJU Int | 2012 | June 2009 –June 2010 | USA | 181 | 86:95 | 45.5 | Procedure related events (PREs) | 43:138 |
York | Prospective questionnaire | J Urol | 2013 | May –Dec 2011 | New Zealand | 50 | 39:11 | 51 (21–77) | Pain score, anxiety, complication rate | 50:0 |
Kuehaus | Prospective cohort | J Urol | 2013 | Nov 2011–May 2012 | Austria and Germany | 124 | 86:38 | 47 (20–79) | Pain score at removal | 13a:111 |
Barnes | Prospective RCT | BJU Int | 2014 | Oct 2011–May 2013 | USA | 68a | 26:42 | 49 | USSQ, pain score, adverse events | 33:38 |
Althaus | Retrospective notes review | J Urol | 2015 | – | USA | 512 | 57:41 | 54 | Dislodgement rates | 98:414 |
Loh-Doyle | Prospective Web-based questionnaire | J Endourol | 2015 | May 2013–Dec 2013 | USA | 571 | 183:388 | – | Pain score, removal preferences | 223:348 |
Kim | Prospective RCT | BMC Urology | 2015 | July 2012–Nov 2014 | Korea | 114 | 78:36 | 50 | USSQ, VAS, patient preference | 58:56 |
Total | 1279 | 600:679 | 483:796 |
RCT randomised controlled trial, PPRE post-procedure related events, USSQ ureteric stent symptom questionnaire, VAS visual analogue scale
aUnderpowered