Skip to main content
. 2018 Feb 18;15(2):283–292. doi: 10.1016/j.jor.2018.01.042

Table 1C.

The randomized controlled trial checklist consisted of 4 main items: selection bias, performance bias, attrition bias and detection bias. Based on the score of their respective subitems, the main items were scored as low, unclear and high risk of bias. For each main item, a low response indicated that the study was designed and conducted in a manner that minimized the risk of bias for that item. An unclear response was given when the information required to score an item was not reported or was not reported clearly. A priori, was decided that studies were excluded if more than 2 out of 4 main items would be scored as high risk of bias on the basis of low methodological quality.

Study Selection bias Performance bias Attrition bias Detection bias Inclusion?
Milano et al27 low low low low Yes
Van der Zwaal et al34 low unclear low unclear Yes
Gumina, 201251 unclear unclear low unclear No
Gumina, 201252 high unclear low unclear No
Milano, 201328 low low low low Yes
Berth et al44 high high high high No
Grasso et al21 low unclear low low Yes
Milano et al28 low unclear low low Yes
Nicholas, 201658 unclear low unclear unclear No
Bryant et al42 low low low low Yes
Kukkonen et al41 low unclear low low Yes