Skip to main content
editorial
. 2018 Feb 22;33(12):e92. doi: 10.3346/jkms.2018.33.e92

Table 1. Features of narrative and systematic reviews.

Narrative review Systematic review
Flexible structure, format may vary across journals Pre-defined strict structure
Often invited and written by subject experts Subject experts as authors are desirable but not mandatory
Specialized training in searches through bibliographic databases and synthesizing evidence-based information is desirable for authors Specialized training in meta-analyses is mandatory for authors
Search strategy is advisable Search strategy is mandatory
Pre-registration of title is not required Pre-registration of title is required (Cochrane/PROSPERO)
No pre-published protocol Pre-published protocol is required
Broad scope, several citable points Narrow scope, few citable points
Quality assessment of included studies is not required Quality assessment/risk of bias analysis is mandatory
Quantitative synthesis of existing data is not required Quantitative synthesis of data may be performed (meta-analysis)
Not considered as original articles Some journals consider systematic reviews with meta-analyses as original research articles

PROSPERO = International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews.