Skip to main content
. 2018 Jan 3;4(2):e000145. doi: 10.1099/mgen.0.000145

Table 1. Overview of culture-independent genome sequencing methodologies applied to Chlamydiae to date.

CRB, Chlamydia-related bacteria; IFU, infection-forming units; IMS, immunomagnetic separation; LPS, lipopolysaccharide; MDA, multiple displacement amplification; WGA, whole genome amplification.

Culture-independent approach Non-targeted (meta)genome capture Targeted genome capture
Method MDA Depletion-enrichment Cell-sorting-MDA IMS-MDA Sequence capture Multiplexed microdroplet PCR
Molecular basis of method (also see Fig. 1 for schematic diagram) Isothermal strand-displacing whole genome amplification of total genomic DNA Depletion of host methylated DNA coupled with WGA of microbial DNA supernatant by MDA Fluorescence-assisted cell sorting coupled with WGA of isolated single cells of interest (identified by PCR) Anti-LPS antibody binding coupled with WGA by MDA Biotinylated RNA probe hybridization to pathogen genome ‘bait’ Microdroplet PCR amplification of multiple DNA fragments spanning the target genome
Sample type(s) applied to (also see Fig. 2 for method selection) Swab Swab, tissue Environmental samples Swab stored in transport media Swab, tissue, urine Swabs, urine
Sample preparation stage at which to apply method After total DNA extraction After total DNA extraction Initial sample, prior to DNA extraction Initial sample, prior to DNA extraction After total DNA extraction After total DNA extraction
Discovery of novel species? Yes Yes Yes No No No
Detection of multiple strains/co-infection? Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Cost per sample* $ $ $$$$ $ $$¶ $$$
Speed* (hands on time) <1 h§ ~3–4 h§ ~30 min – 2 h§ ~5 h§ <1 h ~1–3 h
Sensitivity† Ct value 25|| ~1×103 genome copies per section 315 cells [58] 4 IFU per swab [66]; 1.1×105 genome copies (post-IMS) [65] ~2×103 genome copies per swab [72]; 3.3×105 (urine), 5.5×106 (swab) [69] Not reported
Specificity‡ 99.6 %|| 99 % [55] n/a Up to 95 % [66] 88 % [74] 99 %
Variant detection? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Throughput Moderate Low Low High High Moderate
Limiting factors(s)/requirement(s) Relative abundance of microbial and eukaryotic DNA in sample Relative abundance of microbial and eukaryotic DNA in sample Cells intact; minimal sample treatment
Sample must be cryopreserved
Samples in aquatic suspension are preferred
Cells intact; minimal sample treatment
Suitable characterized surface-exposed antigen
Sample must be preserved in transport media
Reference genome Reference genome
Specific bioinformatics software required
Chlamydial species applied to C. trachomatis Ca. C. sanzinia, Ca. C. corallus, Ca. Similichlamydia epinephelii Novel CRB species C. trachomatis C. trachomatis, C. pecorum, C. pneumoniae, C. psittaci C. trachomatis
Reference(s) [50] [55–57] [58] [64, 65] [69, 72, 74, 75] [77]

*Excluding DNA extraction and sequencing; relative cost to each other.

†Lowest amount of chlamydial DNA for 100 % genome coverage.

‡Highest percentage of non-chlamydial reads still allowing 90–100 % chlamydial genome coverage; will differ depending on sequencing platform and degree of multiplexing.

§MDA amplification step not included in time.

||Only 85 % of genome covered at least once.

¶Cost estimate for 1 : 1 bait/sample ratio.